First of all, as we will be speaking about race for the next several weeks, I feel the need to make a disclaimer. After having discussions about race in many classes, each time as one of very few blacks in a predominantly white class, I have found that often classmates mistakenly look to me for the be-all end-all answer. Let me make it clear that whatever comments I make, are not those of ALL black people, I cannot speak for my race, and should not be expected to. That pressure is too much for me. Whatever I say is my individual perspective as a young black woman in this country, not having had the experiences of all other black people. Some may think that it is inappropriate for me to make such a disclaimer, but as aforementioned, I have been in many discussions concerning race in which ignorance reared its head and people assumed this or that about all blacks based on my input. I would like to avoid that in this case. Now let me begin with my response…..
The thing that Dewey admired most was Petey’s freedom. Freedom to say what ever he wanted to without fear. Freedom to dress how he wanted. Freedom to do what he wanted. Freedom to be, just as he was. Dewey, having assimilated and changed himself to fit the standards of white culture, did not possess such freedoms. Dewey had done what he needed to in order to survive in his business, which was to speak in standard English, dress in plain suits, etc.
The chasm between Dewey and Petey, created by perceived dual ignorance is one that is very familiar to black people. The perceptions are still very prevalent today, even in my own life. I say dual ignorance because both sides believe that the other is ignorant. On the one side there are black people whom are often times lacking in higher education, of lower economic status, living in the inner city (ghetto/hood), and are suffering/truly living the “black experience�. They perceive the opposite group as “sellouts�, “Oreos�, “uppity and bourgeois�, being “white-washed�, not “keeping it real�, etc. This side is illustrated in all of Petey’s accusations of Dewey. This side believes that because people have left the hood, gone to college, found high paying jobs/success, etc (which typically requires at least some assimilation) that they are no longer being true to themselves and ignorant of what it really means to be black.
On the contrary, there is the other side, making a genuine effort to change their situation and do better for themselves. They perceive the other side as ignorant of their lifestyle, and ignorant of what it takes to be successful in this country. Sometimes, this group looks down on the other, just like Dewey’s sideways comments to both his brother and Petey when they were in prison in the beginning of the film. He spoke and behaved in a very condescending manner, just because their life choices had brought them to a very different place than his. Both sides are doing what they think they need to in order to survive/achieve their dreams.
This type of thinking occurs a lot more than one might think. A few months ago, I was speaking with a recent black U of M graduate who moved her hometown and now works for a Fortune 100 company. She told me about how when she goes back home, people treat her differently and make assumptions that she has changed negatively because of her new found success. They accuse her of being a puppet for white people (also known as “shucking and jiving�), tease her for speaking proper English, and make comments they never would have had she not graduated from college and went into the business world. However, she does admit to having changed somewhat, explaining that when in Rome, one must do as the Romans do. She sees it as playing “their� game. Everyone does it, most people are one way at work or school and may be completely different outside of that. Facebook pictures are strong evidence of that. Thus, the conflict witnessed between Dewey and Petey deals with perceptional stereotypes that have yet to be overcome in today’s society. Though Dewey may be envious of Petey’s freedom, Petey is envious of Dewey’s power/success.
.........................................................................................................................................................................................
If the Tonight Show were hosted by an African American or was geared to a black audience, Petey would not have done what he did. Obviously, he had done his routine many times before in front of black audiences, so it wasn’t just him being nervous. Though he was rude and somewhat disrespectful to the audience, the host, and the show itself, in his speech, he clearly explained that he was uncomfortable because they wouldn’t be laughing WITH him, but instead AT him. I do not necessarily agree, but I can definitely see where he is coming from. It reminds me of minstrel shows in the past, where whites dressed up as blacks and made fun of them for entertainment. Blacks are often used (even in today’s media) as comic relief and not taken seriously. To be honest, there are products of pop culture about black culture today such as Aaron McGruder’s “The Boondocks�, certain rap songs, movies, etc that if I were by myself or with other black people, I would find hilarious and feel comfortable joking about because they can identify. However, if I were watching in the presence of white people, I wouldn’t even crack a smile. Sometimes, as a black person, I feel that laughing or making light of things like that gives others permission to do the same and I do not want them to believe that whatever the portrayal is, is the way all black people are or that it’s ok to make the same jokes. Yes, it is certainly a double standard, but it is what it is. I compare it to siblings. There are things that families joke and tease each other about, but if someone outside the family were to hear or say something about, it would be upsetting to them.