Main

April 18, 2006

Nietzsche the Exile, cont.

The aforementioned aphorism raises some serious questions, not the least of which is why I am citing Nietzsche as a vital influence in my theorizing about borders. Nietzsche was certainly not a democrat, did not believe in "equal rights" (which he always puts in quotes), and yet at the same time was fiercely anti-nationalist and anti-racist. This helps to explain, at least in part, his continuing relevance and application by intellectuals throughout the political spectrum. For my purposes, this aphorism is necessary in that it emphasizes the idea of a supra-national sensibilitiy as opposed to a "nationalism and race hatred...[which] take[s] pleasure in the national scabies of the heart and blood poisoning that now leads the nations of Europe to delimit and barricade themselves against each other as if it were a matter of quarantine" (339). Nietzsche was also highly conscious of the fact that the philosopher should be the "bad conscience of his time," a stance that Said will take up later in his developing views on the place of the intellectual in academic and political realms. One of the appealing threads in Nietzsche's thought is this insistence that any patriotism or "petty nationalism" should be avoided at all costs in order to preserve one's intellectual integrity. At a time when the jingoism of the Kaiserreich and virulent anti-Semitism dominated German life, Nietzsche warned against both and advocated both cultural and genetic boundary crossing in order to create the "good European."

Nietzsche the Exile

One of the central ideas of this blog will be the importance of the exile, especially as conceived by Edward Said. Before I discuss Said in future posts, though, I want to point to a precursor to Said, and that is Nietzsche. Nietzsche's wanderings through Europe were borne not just from a desire to find somewhere where his myriad health ailments could be alleviated, but from a strong anti-nationalist impulse and belief in the idea of the "good European," a concept that I think owes a great deal to Goethe's conception of Weltliteratur. The aphorism in which Nietzsche explicates this theme is in Part V of the The Gay Science, written in 1886-87, is fittingly titled "We who are homeless--"

Continue reading "Nietzsche the Exile" »