DOES THE CAUCUS WORK? If not, can we make it?
After scanning a bunch of comments, I wonder if anyone thinks the caucus has any benefits? Perhaps as a political community for the neighborhood? As a way to engage in the messiness of politics? To expand viewpoints on issues? To prioritize issues as a party? A physical, annual opportunity to participate in "the process" ?
If we look at the critical comments as an opportunity for leadership, we can think of some ways to respond to the process as it exists. This could begin with listing what works, and what doesn't. Could other people contribute to this? I'm an officer of a student group Greenlight, that engages with postive "sustainable" activism: recommendations, contributions, and community workshops to design solutions for our current reality.
As overworked architecture students, we're trying to find ways to engage with the wider community to increase our impact and support the consistency of our involvement. To that end, we've committed to having weekly meetings this semester (and yes, that's a big thing for us) at the Purple Onion on University (East Bank). Consider yourselves invited: every Thursday, 11:15am.
Past meetings have diverged into less useful discussions, so I'm hoping to run these more like construction administration meetings: prepare our projects for updates and address potential conflicts or scheduling issues. We'll see how it goes. Point being, perhaps part of the caucus "failure" is due to lack of understanding with regards to the purpose of the event. When/where is this process introduced to participants?
One driver of successful meetings is the ability to prepare and handle business efficiently while face-to-face. As the caucus only happens every four years, and the majority of attendees had no idea what the purpose/process was, the disorganization is understandable. The caucus needs to simultaneously educate, organize, and engage with a variety of people and issues.
Potential solutions could include the following (some of these may be available in some fashion): - annual meetings to discuss issues and direction of party - smaller committees to work on specific issues (similar to nominating leaders for voting mobilization) - online continued engagment: forums for districts where registered voters can consistently connect (this could also provide a great resource to district representatives) - expanding the political education process in general education curriculum: when we learn about the branches of government, couldn't we also learn the differences between democratic engagement with the populace between states? a comparative analysis of how our society operates...
The last comment is grown from an issue we discussed at our small table of four at the DFL caucus I attended with a friend. We sat with two elderly women, one who used to attend frequently, but stopped in the 1990s, and the other who had always lived in Minnesota, but never attended. We discussed the potential for the caucus to really engage the community: with limited hours, this seems compromised, but could be counteracted by making it a national holiday of sorts - everyone gets time off from work. Frankly, I find the concept as important as religious holidays, but then our society doesn't provide holidays for all religions either... Our overall concern is that, although this may be respectful and successful in Minnesota, it most likely would not work in larger urban areas. Having attended town meetings throughout the east coast, I've seen the frustration and damage done by less respectful participants in the process. This was the first "community" meeting that had a sense of decorum and that may be a direct result of everyone feeling that at some point, their voice would be heard. Greenwich (Connecticut) town meetings in particular are famous for going late into the night and postponing agenda items in an effort to allow everyone to have their say. They're also famous for filibustering-length rants by vocal citizens...
I'd like to hear what others think. Any ideas for our caucus and/or for my own concerns with Greenlight?
...thanks
Comments
I want to comment about something that is related and yet unrelated. I meant to mention this in my blog but ran a different direction with it. The first question you ask is whether or not the caucus has any benefits. I went to the caucus for the first time this year and I wasn't sure what exactly I would get out of it. However, I found that what was the most rewarding or beneficial to me was not what the true goal of the caucus was. This past year I bought a house in the suburbs and due to my busy work schedule and taking classes, I'm rarely home or around my neighborhood. This was the first chance I have ever met my neighbors and that in itself was beneficial. I sat next to an older gentleman, (70's) who was absolutely amazing. He explained to me what was going on, he shared with me his history and when it came time to choose delegates he encouraged me to volunteer. Victor is a very active man in my community and has motivated me to become more active, even if I don't have a lot of time to commit. I realized that I can make time to go to a meeting once a month. We talked about my previous involvement in the school board when I was in high school and he made me realize that while I may not be part of the local school district now, I might someday and it is never to early to start.
So, I found the caucus to be incredibly beneficial. I never would have made that connection and I never would have been motivated to get involved - maybe its not at the state level, but I think I'm starting in a good place.
Posted by: Jen | February 12, 2008 11:55 AM
I like the idea of Caucus Day. It is as important as Christmas, which usually brings families together whether or not they agree or disagree. They can stand one another for one day. The only thing better than making the caucus a holiday, would be to let all parties caucus together by their precinct and let them discuss what they believe in...I think they would find we all pretty much want the same thing...respect, love and compassion. For too long the body has been separated into parts and not viewed as a whole. The interdependance on the other has been ignored. The same is true of our communities. We are separated by labels...young, old, black, white, conservatives, liberals, gays and straights. Once we recognize the importance of how we all contribute, how our differences are beneficial (for they can create balance) we can then find harmony.
If one looks at nature we know...too much of one thing creates an imbalance. It is the combination of the yin and the yang that creates harmony.
Posted by: Bette Jo | February 12, 2008 02:01 PM