Go to HHH home page.
Smart Politics
 


Election Profile: Minnesota's 5th Congressional District (2008)

Bookmark and Share

Smart Politics is running a series of election profiles of all the Upper Midwestern U.S. Senate and U.S. House races leading up to the November 4th elections. The series will culminate with Smart Politics' official projections. The twenty-first profile in the series is Minnesota's 5th Congressional District race.

Candidates:
DFL: Keith Ellison (1-term incumbent)
Republican: Barb Davis White
Independence: Bill McGaughey

District Geography:
Minnesota's 5th Congressional District comprises the eastern (Minneapolis) region of Hennepin County and the southern tip of Anoka County.

History:
Keith Ellison filled the seat of retiring 14-term DFL Representative Martin Olav Sabo in 2006 by defeating Republican Alan Fine by a 34.3-point margin. Fine narrowly edged Independence Party candidate Tammy Lee, 21.3 to 21.0 percent (the strongest showing to date of an Independence Party candidate in a Minnesota U.S. House race). The closest a challenger came to unseating Sabo during his 28-year tenure in this Democratic stronghold was in 1994 - when Dorothy Legrand fell 24.6 points short - an unsuccessful bid during the 'Republican revolution.'

The DFL has won the last 23 races in the 5th District dating back to 1962 (1 by Ellison, 14 by Sabo, and 8 by Donald Fraser) by an average margin of 34.8 points. Prior to 1962, Democrats carried the 5th District only one time, in 1902 (John Lind). Republicans won 37 of the remaining 39 5th District contests from 1890 through 1960, throughout its different geographic variations, only failing to carry the district in 1890 (Kittel Halvorson, running under the Farmers Alliance-Prohibition label) and 1936 (Dewey W. Johnson of the Farmer-Labor Party).

Ellison is the first black U.S. Representative from Minnesota, as well as the first Muslim in Congress altogether. Ellison currently serves on the House Financial Services and Judiciary Committees. The Representative's stated Congressional priorities are "promoting peace, prosperity for working families, and promoting civil and human rights.

Republican Barb Davis White, a minister, is running on a platform that is pro-life, against federal control over education policy, and encouraging of business development in the district. White also advocates making the Bush tax cuts permanent, repealing ethanol subsidies, developing nuclear and natural gas energy, and withdrawing troops from Iraq only when the nation has stabilized.

Bill McGaughey is the lone third party candidate in the race. McGaughey is running a campaign emphasizing solutions to the U.S. trade deficit (anti-NAFTA and supporting tariffs on imports to help offset the imbalance that results from low-cost labor in developing countries). McGaughey also supports the development of alternative energies, such as wind, to help eliminate the oil-based component of the U.S. trade deficit. The Independence Party candidate also believes the United States should end its "war-based economy and empower the United Nations to step in and police the world.

Outlook:
Ellison serves the most reliably Democratic district in the state and, as such, the race is always for second place in the 5th CD. Third parties have garnered at least 5 percent of the vote in every 5th District contest since 1996. But while Republicans have only eclipsed 30 percent of the vote in the district in two elections since 1972, the Independence Party probably had its best chance for a second place finish last year with Tammy Lee.

1 Comment


  • How can Minnesotans be so foolish as to elect a man whose biggest financial backing comes from the extremist Islamic group-CAIR-a 5th columnist organization here in America, it's executive director is known sympathizer/supporter of terrorist group Hamas. Nihad Awad also know as Nihad Hammad has a very interesting history-check it out for yourself, and if you must keep a democrat in this seat, elect one that will be serving you, and not serving the Islamic extremists here and abroad.

  • Leave a comment


    Remains of the Data

    A Brief History of "Representative Smith"

    A look back at the 115 "Smiths" to serve in the House as newly-minted U.S. Representative Jason Smith of Missouri adds his name to the roster.

    Political Crumbs

    The 40 Percent Floor

    Although Republicans have won 23 of 39 Indiana gubernatorial races since the first time a GOP candidate was on the ballot in 1860, Democrats have suffered few blow-out defeats during this span. In fact, the Democratic nominee has eclipsed the 40 percent mark in all 39 contests. The Republicans cannot quite claim the same, falling below 40 percent just once with nominee Linley Pearson during the gubernatorial election of 1992 when Evan Byah won his second term. Democrats have a streak of 47 consecutive contests reaching the 40 percent mark - doing so every cycle since the party first fielded a candidate in the race for governor of 1834.


    Curse of the '4'?

    Big-name Republicans are not coming out of the woodwork yet to challenge Al Franken in Minnesota's 2014 U.S. Senate race, and there is not much chatter of the GOP picking off one of the five DFL-held U.S. House seats either. Over the last century, Minnesota Republican U.S. House candidates have not fared all that well in cycles ending in '4' - losing seats in five of these cycles (1914, 1924, 1944, 1954, 1974), holding serve in four others (1964, 1984, 1994, 2004), and gaining seats just one time (1934, after redistricting had been delayed one cycle with all nine seats voted at-large in 1932). Perhaps the Republican Party's best chance for a pick up in the Gopher State in 2014 is if 12-term Democrat Collin Peterson retires after nearly a quarter century on Capitol Hill. The 7th CD has the second largest GOP lean in the state.


    more POLITICAL CRUMBS

    Humphrey School Sites
    CSPG
    Humphrey New Media Hub

    Issues />

<div id=
    Abortion
    Afghanistan
    Budget and taxes
    Campaign finances
    Crime and punishment
    Economy and jobs
    Education
    Energy
    Environment
    Foreign affairs
    Gender
    Health
    Housing
    Ideology
    Immigration
    Iraq
    Media
    Military
    Partisanship
    Race and ethnicity
    Reapportionment
    Redistricting
    Religion
    Sexuality
    Sports
    Terrorism
    Third parties
    Transportation
    Voting