Go to HHH home page.
Smart Politics
 


Rehberg Would Make GOP History by Defeating Tester in MT US Senate Race

Bookmark and Share

Sitting at-large representatives have unseated U.S Senators just 17 percent of the time over the last 100 years - a feat never accomplished by a Republican

The official announcement Saturday by six-term Republican U.S. Representative Denny Rehberg (MT-at large) that he would challenge Democrat Jon Tester in 2012 sets up one of the more exciting U.S. Senate races next year.

Rehberg has already framed the race as not just a fight for control of Montana's seat but also for the U.S. Senate, in which the Democrat caucus currently holds a 53 to 47-seat advantage.

Rehberg, it would seem, is in a stronger position to defeat an incumbent Senator than most members of the U.S. House across the country, as he holds an at-large seat, and thus has high name recognition from his six statewide victories dating back to 2000, in addition to his 1992 victory on Marc Racicot's gubernatorial ticket when he was elected Lieutenant Governor.

But Rehberg should be warned that history shows few have succeeded when taking similar pathways to the U.S. Senate.

A Smart Politics study finds that sitting at-large representatives from single-seat states have defeated U.S. Senate incumbents just 17 percent of the time over the last 100 years of U.S. Senate elections.

And no Republican has pulled off this feat to date.

(Note: This analysis only examines at-large representatives who serve states, like Montana, with a single U.S. Representative since popular vote U.S. Senate elections were introduced a century ago: Alaska (1958-present), Arizona (1912-1940), Delaware (1912-present), Montana (1992-present), Nevada (1912-1980), New Mexico (1912-1940), North Dakota (1972-present), South Dakota (1982-present), Vermont (1932-present), and Wyoming (1912-present). Excluded are states that elected multiple at-large representatives during election cycles either by design (e.g. North Dakota 1932-1960) or due to the failure to construct congressional districts (e.g. Minnesota in 1932). Also excluded were states that occasionally elected the occasional at-large representative along with a full complement of district-level representatives (e.g. New York 1932-1944)).

Overall, six individuals who at one time were at-large Representatives have defeated Senatorial incumbents, against 19 defeats. However, three of those victories were won while the candidates were not serving in their at-large seat.

Former Delaware at-large representatives James Boggs (in 1960) and Tom Carper (in 2000) were both serving as Governor when they were elected to the U.S. Senate - defeating incumbents J. Allen Frear and William Roth respectively eight years out from serving in their at-large position.

South Dakota's John Thune was also out of office for two years when he defeated incumbent Tom Daschle in 2004 (having failed while at the tail end of his at-large service against Tim Johnson in 2002).

That means just 3 of 17 sitting at-large members have ousted incumbents in U.S. Senate races - all of them Democrats:

· Carl Hayden served eight terms in the U.S. House as Arizona's lone representative before defeating one-term GOP incumbent Ralph Cameron by 16.7 points in 1926.

· Tom Daschle nipped one-term Republican incumbent James Abnor by 3.2 points in 1986 after serving four terms in the House - the last two of which as the Mount Rushmore State's at-large representative.

· Tim Johnson - who succeeded Daschle in the House for five terms - beat three-term GOP incumbent Larry Pressler by 2.6 points in 1996.

On each of the 14 other occasions, sitting at-large representatives were defeated when trying to knock a U.S. Senator out of office:

Fate of Sitting At-Large Representatives When Vying for Incumbent-Held U.S. Senate Seats, 1912-Present

State
Year
Representative
Party
Terms
Fate
NM
1918
William Walton
Democrat
1
Lost
NV
1918
Edwin Roberts
GOP
4
Lost
NV
1922
Samuel Arentz*
GOP
1
Lost
WY
1922
Frank Mondell
GOP
13
Lost
AZ
1926
Carl Hayden
Democrat
8
Won
WY
1928
Charles Winter
GOP
3
Lost
DE
1934
Wilbur Adams
Democrat
1
Lost
WY
1934
Vincent Carter
GOP
3
Lost
NM
1934
Dennis Chavez
Democrat
2
Lost
NM
1940
John Dempsey*
Democrat
3
Lost
DE
1954
Herbert Warburton
GOP
1
Lost
NV
1956
Clarence Young
GOP
2
Lost
WY
1970
John Wold
GOP
1
Lost
WY
1982
James Santini*
Democrat
4
Lost**
SD
1986
Tom Daschle
Democrat
4
Won
SD
1996
Tim Johnson
Democrat
5
Won
SD
2002
John Thune
GOP
3
Lost
MT
2012
Denny Rehberg
GOP
6
???
* Did not make the general election ballot. ** Incumbent ended up losing to a different challenger. Includes only at-large representatives from states with a single U.S. House seat. Terms tallied at the time of U.S. Senate challenge (Samuel Arentz and John Dempsey were later elected to the U.S. House after their failed Senate bids). Table compiled by Smart Politics.

Rehberg is therefore seeking to become the first sitting Republican at-large Representative to win a U.S. Senate seat from a single-member delegation state.

The good news for Rehberg is that two of three previous at-large representatives who had at least five terms under their belt were successful in winning a seat in the nation' upper legislative chamber (Rehberg has six).

Meanwhile, sitting at-large representatives have had a leg up over their competition in open seat races, however, winning nine contests and losing just five over the past century.

When tallying both races against incumbents and for open seats, sitting at-large representatives have won 12 of 31 races over the past century, or 38.7 percent of the time.

In total, 37 of 88 sitting or former at-large representatives eventually vied for their state's Senate seat at some point in their political career, or 42 percent.

Follow Smart Politics on Twitter.

Previous post: No GOP Challenger Yet For Amy Klobuchar? No Problem
Next post: Former Pawlenty Chief of Staff Bob Schroeder to speak at Humphrey School

Leave a comment


Remains of the Data

Is There a Presidential Drag On Gubernatorial Elections?

Only five of the 20 presidents to serve since 1900 have seen their party win a majority of gubernatorial elections during their administrations, and only one since JFK.

Political Crumbs

Strike Three for Miller-Meeks

Iowa Republicans had a banner day on November 4th, picking up both a U.S. Senate seat and one U.S. House seat, but Mariannette Miller-Meeks' defeat in her third attempt to oust Democrat Dave Loebsack in the 2nd CD means the GOP will not have a monopoly on the state's congressional delegation in the 114th Congress. The loss by Miller-Meeks (following up her defeats in 2008 and 2010) means major party nominees who lost their first two Iowa U.S. House races are now 0 for 10 the third time around in Iowa history. Miller-Meeks joins Democrat William Leffingwell (1858, 1868, 1870), Democrat Anthony Van Wagenen (1894, 1912 (special), 1912), Democrat James Murtagh (1906, 1914, 1916), Democrat Clair Williams (1944, 1946, 1952), Democrat Steven Carter (1948, 1950, 1956), Republican Don Mahon (1966, 1968, 1970), Republican Tom Riley (1968, 1974, 1976), Democrat Eric Tabor (1986, 1988, 1990), and Democrat Bill Gluba (1982, 1988, 2004) on the Hawkeye State's Three Strikes list.


Larry Pressler Wins the Silver

Larry Pressler may have fallen short in his long-shot, underfunded, and understaffed bid to return to the nation's upper legislative chamber, but he did end up notching the best showing for a non-major party South Dakota U.S. Senate candidate in more than 90 years. Pressler won 17.1 percent of the vote which is the best showing for an independent or third party U.S. Senate candidate in the state since 1920 when non-partisan candidate Tom Ayres won 24.1 percent in a race won by Republican Peter Norbeck. Overall, Pressler's 17.1 percent is good for the second best mark for a non-major party candidate across the 35 U.S. Senate contests in South Dakota history. Independent and third party candidates have appeared on the South Dakota U.S. Senate ballot just 25 times over the last century and only three have reached double digits: Pressler in 2014 and Ayres in 1920 and 1924 (12.1 percent). Pressler's defeat means he won't become the oldest candidate elected to the chamber in South Dakota history nor notch the record for the longest gap in service in the direct election era.


more POLITICAL CRUMBS

Humphrey School Sites
CSPG
Humphrey New Media Hub

Issues />

<div id=
Abortion
Afghanistan
Budget and taxes
Campaign finances
Crime and punishment
Economy and jobs
Education
Energy
Environment
Foreign affairs
Gender
Health
Housing
Ideology
Immigration
Iraq
Media
Military
Partisanship
Race and ethnicity
Reapportionment
Redistricting
Religion
Sexuality
Sports
Terrorism
Third parties
Transportation
Voting