Go to HHH home page.
Smart Politics
 


Tarryl Clark in 2012: How Many Minnesota U.S. Representatives Lost Their First House Race?

Bookmark and Share

Nearly one out of six Minnesota U.S. Representatives in history did not win their first congressional race (21 of 134)

Tarryl Clark's announcement last week that she was running for Congress again in 2012 was perhaps more noteworthy for her purported decision to take up residency in Chip Cravaack's 8th CD than for her attempting another congressional campaign in the first instance in light of her failed 2010 bid.

Of course, with some U.S. Representatives willing to consider moving half-way across the country to find the right House district, it should come as no surprise that challengers will also consider cherry-picking the most feasible district to win a U.S. House contest, particularly in a redistricting year.

But will Minnesotans back a congressional candidate who already ran and lost?

And just how common is it for a Minnesota U.S. Representative to get elected to Congress after previously failing in a general election campaign?

A Smart Politics review of Minnesota's more than 575 general and special U.S. House elections since the late 1850s finds that 16 percent of the state's U.S. Representatives were not successful in their first general election campaign, or 21 of 134 U.S. Representatives.

Two, of course, are currently serving in the state's congressional delegation.

DFLer Collin Peterson and Republican John Kline each lost not one but two elections to the U.S. House as their party's nominee before eventually claiming victory.

In 1984, Peterson lost to GOPer Arlan Stangeland by 14.1 points and then by just 121 votes two years later in 1986.

Peterson would eventually upend Stangeland in 1990 by 7.1 points.

Kline was the 1998 Republican nominee during his failed attempt to defeat DFL incumbent Bill Luther in the 6th CD.

Kline lost that race by 4.0 points, and then lost again to Luther in 2000 by 1.6 points.

The two candidates would square off for a third consecutive cycle in the newly drawn 2nd CD with Kline emerging this time as an 11.1-point victor.

Kline and Peterson are two of the three Minnesota congressmen to win election to the U.S. House on their third attempt, with the other being Republican Franklin Ellsworth nearly 100 years ago in 1914.

Ellsworth first ran for Congress in 1910, when he lost the state's 2nd CD race to future Democratic Governor Winfield Hammond by 8.4 points.

Ellsworth challenged Hammond again in 1912, losing this time by 5.5 points.

With Hammond running for governor in 1914, Ellsworth took advantage of the open-seat race and finally broke through with a 23.8 victory in a four-candidate field.

But the Kline and Peterson success stories of the last few generations are not aberrations.

Over the last 40 years, a total of five of the 26 newly-elected Minnesotans to the U.S. House, or 19 percent, won their seat after losing on their first try.

In addition to Kline and Peterson, other practice-makes-perfect success stories include those of DFLers Bob Bergland (losing in 1968 and winning in 1970), Richard Nolan (losing in 1972 and winning in 1974), and Gerry Sikorski (losing in 1978 and winning in 1982).

The first congressional candidate to win election on his second attempt from the Gopher State was Republican Cyrus Aldrich before the Civil War.

Aldrich was one of six candidates on the ballot in the state's inaugural 1857 race that elected two Democratic at-large representatives to the House. Aldrich came in fourth place with 16.2 percent of the vote.

Two years later, Aldrich received the most votes of the four candidates in that cycle's two seat at-large U.S. House contest with 27.5 percent.

As for Tarryl Clark not stopping to take a breath and running for Congress again in 2012, it is certainly not without precedent for a congressional candidate to try to win a seat in back-to-back cycles.

In fact, of the 21 U.S. Representatives from Minnesota who won on their second (or third) attempt, the average number of years between their first appearance on the general election ballot and their first U.S. House election victory is just 3.7 years, with 12 notching their victory in the very next cycle.

The longest amount of time between a candidate's first defeat and eventual victory is held by Democrat Winfield Hammond, who lost his 1892 2nd CD race to Republican James McCleary by 18.4 points before knocking off McCleary 14 years later in 1906 by 4.0 points.

Clark, of course, is also no ordinary candidate, having shattered the Gopher State's congressional fundraising record for a challenger in a U.S. House race with $4.7 raised during her 2010 campaign.

However, that gaudy tally had as much to do with Clark's opponent, Michele Bachmann (who raised north of $13.5 million) as her own campaign. A potential matchup against Cravaack would likely not put nearly as much money into her coffers.

In addition to John Kline, two other U.S. House members from Minnesota won in a different congressional district from their first attempt: Thomas Schall (losing in the 5th, winning in the 10th) and Gerry Sikorski (losing in the 1st, winning in the 6th).

Another five representatives toggled between at-large and congressional district races in their various attempts.

Minnesota U.S. Representatives Who Lost the First Time They Appeared on the General Election Ballot

Year
U.S. Rep.
Party
First Attempts
1859
Cyrus Aldrich
Republican
1857
1868
Morton Wilkinson
Republican
1857
1894
Joel Heatwole
Republican
1892
1906
Winfield Hammond
Democrat
1892
1914
Thomas Schall
Progressive
1912
1914
Franklin Ellsworth
Republican
1910, 1912
1922
Ole Kvale
Farmer-Labor
1920
1932
Francis Shoemaker
Farmer-Labor
1930
1932
Henry Arens
Farmer-Labor
1928
1932
Einar Hoidale
Democrat
1929
1936
Dewey Johnson
Farmer-Labor
1934
1936
Henry Teigan
Farmer-Labor
1932
1938
H. Carl Andersen
Republican
1936
1940
Joseph O'Hara
Republican
1938
1944
William Gallagher
DFL
1942*
1948
Roy Wier
DFL
1946
1970
Bob Bergland
DFL
1968
1974
Richard Nolan
DFL
1972
1982
Gerry Sikorski
DFL
1978
1990
Collin C. Peterson
DFL
1984, 1986
2002
John Kline
Republican
1998, 2000
Note: Far right column denotes years in which the future U.S. Representative appeared on the general election ballot in a losing effort. * Gallagher ran as a Democrat in 1942. Data compiled by Smart Politics.

Follow Smart Politics on Twitter.

Previous post: Humphrey Event: Direct National Popular Vote in Presidential Elections
Next post: Could Tommy Thompson Win Wisconsin's U.S. Senate Seat?

Leave a comment


Remains of the Data

No Free Passes: States With 2 Major Party Candidates in Every US House Race

Indiana has now placed candidates from both major parties on the ballot in a nation-best 189 consecutive U.S. House races, with New Hampshire, Minnesota, Idaho, and Montana also north of 100 in a row.

Political Crumbs

Gubernatorial Highs and Lows

Two sitting governors currently hold the record for the highest gubernatorial vote ever received in their respective states by a non-incumbent: Republican Matt Mead of Wyoming (65.7 percent in 2010) and outgoing GOPer Dave Heineman of Nebraska (73.4 percent in 2006). Republican Gary Herbert of Utah had not previously won a gubernatorial contest when he notched a state record 64.1 percent for his first victory in 2010, but was an incumbent at the time after ascending to the position in 2009 after the early departure of Jon Huntsman. Meanwhile, two sitting governors hold the record in their states for the lowest mark ever recorded by a winning gubernatorial candidate (incumbent or otherwise): independent-turned-Democrat Lincoln Chafee of Rhode Island (36.1 percent in 2010) and Democrat Terry McAuliffe of Virginia (47.8 percent in 2013).


An Idaho Six Pack

Two-term Idaho Republican Governor Butch Otter only polled at 39 percent in a recent PPP survey of the state's 2014 race - just four points ahead of Democratic businessman A.J. Balukoff. Otter's low numbers reflect his own struggles as a candidate (witness his weak primary win against State Senator Russ Fulcher) combined with the opportunity for disgruntled Idahoans to cast their votes for one of four third party and independent candidates, who collectively received the support of 12 percent of likely voters: Libertarian John Bujak, the Constitution Party's Steve Pankey, and independents Jill Humble and Pro-Life (aka Marvin Richardson). The six candidate options in a gubernatorial race sets an all-time record in the Gem State across the 46 elections conducted since statehood. The previous high water mark of five candidates was reached in seven previous cycles: 1902, 1904, 1908, 1912, 1914, 1966, and 2010.


more POLITICAL CRUMBS

Humphrey School Sites
CSPG
Humphrey New Media Hub

Issues />

<div id=
Abortion
Afghanistan
Budget and taxes
Campaign finances
Crime and punishment
Economy and jobs
Education
Energy
Environment
Foreign affairs
Gender
Health
Housing
Ideology
Immigration
Iraq
Media
Military
Partisanship
Race and ethnicity
Reapportionment
Redistricting
Religion
Sexuality
Sports
Terrorism
Third parties
Transportation
Voting