Go to HHH home page.
Smart Politics
 


Rounds Seeks 1st US Senate Win for ex-South Dakota Governor

Bookmark and Share

No former governor has ever won a U.S. Senate seat in South Dakota, with the last sitting governor to do so 70 years ago

mikerounds10.jpgFormer two-term South Dakota Governor Mike Rounds launched his 2014 U.S. Senate campaign Thursday, in what Republicans expect will be one of their best bets to pick up a seat in the nation's upper legislative chamber in two years.

While Republicans have stumbled in states ripe for the party's picking over the last two cycles due to flawed candidates emerging from the GOP primary (e.g. Delaware and Nevada in 2010, Indiana and Missouri in 2012), Rounds is a popular, known quantity in the Mount Rushmore State and would be a legitimate opponent for three-term Democratic incumbent Tim Johnson.

However, it is not a given that Rounds, who has been out of office for nearly two years, will have a clear path to the nomination, with at-large GOP U.S. Representative Kristi Noem a potential contender to make a run at Tim Johnson's seat.

In fact, ex-governors in South Dakota have struck out every time they've sought a U.S. Senate seat over the decades - with only one even attempting such a move since the end of World War II.

A Smart Politics analysis finds that no ex-governor has been elected to the U.S. Senate from South Dakota in state history, with five of the last six campaigns by ex- or sitting governors ending in failure since the Great Depression.

Rather than make a controversial run at the U.S. Senate at the end of his term and challenge popular one-term Republican John Thune in 2010, Rounds opted to sit out two years and take his chances against Tim Johnson.

However, there is no historical blueprint for success in the Mount Rushmore State that Rounds can use as a guide to win a senate seat:

· Republican Governor Frank Byrne (1913-1916) was the first ex-governor to try to win a U.S. Senate seat from South Dakota.

Byrne was two years removed from the end of his second term in 1918 when he lost a two-way GOP primary to Thomas Sterling by 11 points, 55.5 to 44.5 percent.

· Former two-term Democratic governor Tom Berry (1933-1936) ran for the U.S. Senate in 1938, but was defeated by Chan Gurney by 5.0 points, 52.5 to 47.5 percent.

Berry then made a second attempt at a U.S. Senate run in 1942, but was defeated in the general election by 17.4 points by sitting GOP governor Harlan Bushfield.

· Former two-term Republican governor Archie Gubbrud (1961-1964) attempted to unseat one-term Democratic incumbent George McGovern in 1968, but lost by 13.6 points, 56.8 percent to 43.2 percent.

The last sitting governor to win a senate seat from South Dakota was Harlan Bushfield, 70 years ago.

Bushfield defeated his Democratic gubernatorial opponents by eight and 10 points in 1938 and 1940 before embarking on his U.S. Senate run at the end of his second term.

He faced former two-term Democratic governor Tom Berry who had knocked out U.S. Senator (and former governor William Bulow) in the party's primary that year.

Bushfield cruised to a 17.4-point victory in the governor on ex-governor matchup, but died before his term ended in 1948.

In addition to Bushfield, the remaining four South Dakota governors who enjoyed successful U.S. Senate bids during the early part of the 20th Century - all had one thing in common: they won their seat while still serving as governor:

· Republican Coe Crawford (1907-1908) was the first governor from the Mouth Rushmore State to win a U.S. Senate seat, doing so at the end of his first term in 1908.

· Republican Governor Peter Norbeck (1917-1920) was elected to the U.S. Senate at the end of his second term as governor in 1920.

· Republican Governor William McMaster (1921-1924) won a U.S. Senate seat at the end of his second term in office in 1924.

· Democrat William Bulow (1927-1930) was elected to the senate at the end of his second term in office in 1930.

Two other sitting governors launched U.S. Senate bids, but came up short:

The most recent South Dakotan to serve as governor and vie for a senate seat was the late Bill Janklow.

While wrapping up his second four-year term as governor in 1986, Janklow launched a primary challenge against one-term Republican U.S. Senator James Abdnor.

Abdnor defeated Janklow by nine points in the GOP primary - 54.5 percent to 45.5 percent.

The other sitting governor who lost his U.S. Senate bid was Republican Leslie Jensen.

Jensen served as governor from 1937-1939 and lost in a four-way 1938 GOP primary to Chan Gurney, 46.8 to 38.7 percent.

Interestingly, all five sitting South Dakota governors who managed to win a U.S. Senate seat did not go out on their own terms - either losing the party's nomination, losing reelection, or dying in office:

· Republican Coe Crawford lost his renomination bid for a second term in the senate in 1914.

· Republican William McMaster was defeated in his 1930 reelection campaign for a second term.

· Republican Peter Norbeck died in his third term in office in 1936.

· Democrat William Bulow was defeated in the 1942 primary after two terms.

· Republican Harlan Bushfield died in his first term in office in 1948.

U.S. Senate Candidacies by Ex- or Sitting South Dakota Governors Since Statehood

Governor
Party
Served
US Senate bid
Gap
Result
Coe Crawford
GOP
1907-1908
1908
In office
Won
Frank Byrne
GOP
1913-1916
1918
2 years
Lost primary
Peter Norbeck
GOP
1917-1920
1920
In office
Won
William McMaster
GOP
1921-1924
1924
In office
Won
William Bulow
Democrat
1927-1930
1930
In office
Won
Tom Berry
Democrat
1933-1936
1938
2 years
Lost general
Leslie Jensen
GOP
1937-1938
1938
In office
Lost primary
Tom Berry
Democrat
1933-1936
1942
6 years
Lost general
Harlan Bushfield
GOP
1939-1942
1942
In office
Won
Archie Gubbrud
GOP
1961-1964
1964
4 years
Lost general
William Janklow
GOP
1979-1986
1986
In office
Lost primary
Note: Gubernatorial terms extend into the first week of the subsequent odd-numbered year. Table compiled by Smart Politics.

Follow Smart Politics on Twitter.

Previous post: Longshots At-Large
Next post: Study: Governors Have No Pull Helping Presidential Nominees Carry Their State

Leave a comment


Remains of the Data

Strange Bedfellows: A Historical Review of Divided US Senate Delegations

Over the last century, states have been twice as likely to be represented by a single political party in the U.S. Senate than have a split delegation; only Delaware, Iowa, and Illinois have been divided more than half the time.

Political Crumbs

Haugh to Reach New Heights

The North Carolina U.S. Senate race between Democratic incumbent Kay Hagan and Republican Thom Tillis may go down to the wire next Tuesday, but along the way Libertarian nominee Sean Haugh is poised to set a state record for a non-major party candidate. Haugh, who previously won 1.5 percent of the vote in the Tar Heel State's 2002 race, has polled at or above five percent in 10 of the last 12 polls that included his name. The current high water mark for a third party or independent candidate in a North Carolina U.S. Senate election is just 3.3 percent, recorded by Libertarian Robert Emory back in 1992. Only one other candidate has eclipsed the three percent mark - Libertarian Christopher Cole with 3.1 percent in 2008.


Gubernatorial Highs and Lows

Two sitting governors currently hold the record for the highest gubernatorial vote ever received in their respective states by a non-incumbent: Republican Matt Mead of Wyoming (65.7 percent in 2010) and outgoing GOPer Dave Heineman of Nebraska (73.4 percent in 2006). Republican Gary Herbert of Utah had not previously won a gubernatorial contest when he notched a state record 64.1 percent for his first victory in 2010, but was an incumbent at the time after ascending to the position in 2009 after the early departure of Jon Huntsman. Meanwhile, two sitting governors hold the record in their states for the lowest mark ever recorded by a winning gubernatorial candidate (incumbent or otherwise): independent-turned-Democrat Lincoln Chafee of Rhode Island (36.1 percent in 2010) and Democrat Terry McAuliffe of Virginia (47.8 percent in 2013).


more POLITICAL CRUMBS

Humphrey School Sites
CSPG
Humphrey New Media Hub

Issues />

<div id=
Abortion
Afghanistan
Budget and taxes
Campaign finances
Crime and punishment
Economy and jobs
Education
Energy
Environment
Foreign affairs
Gender
Health
Housing
Ideology
Immigration
Iraq
Media
Military
Partisanship
Race and ethnicity
Reapportionment
Redistricting
Religion
Sexuality
Sports
Terrorism
Third parties
Transportation
Voting