Go to HHH home page.
Smart Politics
 


The Most Competitive States for Gubernatorial Elections Since 1900

Bookmark and Share

New Mexico's races have been the most narrowly decided followed by Indiana and Ohio; Illinois captures top honors since the Reagan Revolution with Rhode Island the one to watch since the Republican Revolution

newmexicoseal10.pngGubernatorial races have certainly provided high drama across the nation over the last four years.

The most recent gubernatorial elections in 19 states were decided by single digits with 14 of these decided by less than five points: Connecticut, Florida, Illinois, Indiana, Maine, Minnesota, Montana, New Jersey, Ohio, Oregon, Rhode Island, South Carolina, Washington, and West Virginia.

Three of these had a victory margin of less than one point: Connecticut, Illinois, and Minnesota.

The vote for governor in many of these states was narrower than had been seen for several decades:

· Florida (2010, 1.2 points): closest since 1876, second closest ever.
· Montana (2012, 1.6 points): closest since 1892, second closest ever.
· Connecticut (2010, 0.6 points): closest since 1954.
· Oregon (2010, 1.5 points): closest since 1956.
· Indiana (2012, 2.9 points): closest since 1960.
· Minnesota (2010, 0.4 points): closest since 1962.
· West Virginia (2011, 2.5 points): closest since 1968.

Over the next 19+ months, 38 races for governor will be held in states across the country.

With the GOP dominating the political landscape and picking up several seats in the 2009-2010 cycles, the expectation is that if there is any movement it will be a pull-back with Democrats recapturing a few seats in 2013-2014.

At the very least, the Democratic Party is expected to be more competitive in many of these states that they lost over the last few years.

But which states have historically yielded the most competitive gubernatorial races over the decades?

And which states are providing the most nail-biters today?

A Smart Politics analysis of 1,829 gubernatorial elections since 1900 finds that New Mexico has consistently been the most competitive state across all measures with 80 percent of its contests decided by single digits and 44 percent decided by less than five points.

Since the turn of the 20th Century, the average victory margin in the more than 1,800 races for governor has been 20.8 points nationwide.

That margin has dipped in recent decades - 18.2 points since 1946, 16.2 points since 1965 - due in part to Republicans gradually competing and then thriving in southern states.

Slightly more than two in five races since 1900 yielded gubernatorial victories by single-digit margins (767, 41.9 percent) with nearly one in four determined by less than five points (425, 23.2 percent).

New Mexico sets the pace with its 39 gubernatorial elections decided by a nation-low average of 7.5 points.

Only three other states boast an average victory margin in single digits during this 110+ year span: Indiana at 9.3 points, Ohio at 9.8 points, and Alaska at 9.9 points.

Connecticut and Missouri are tied at #5 at 10.2 points followed by Illinois (10.3 points), New Jersey (10.5 points), and Hawaii and West Virginia (11.0 points) to round out the Top 10.

Of these Top 10 states, New Jersey will hold its next election this November with Alaska, Connecticut, Hawaii, Illinois, New Mexico, and Ohio doing so in 2014.

Despite the aforementioned razor-thin margins in Connecticut (0.6 points) and Illinois (0.9 points) the last time around, only Ohio is currently garnering significant attention among these traditionally competitive states with incumbents expected to hold in the others.

In 2010, Dan Malloy's win in Connecticut over Tom Foley was the second closest race in the nation behind Minnesota and the Nutmeg State's narrowest gubernatorial victory margin in 56 years when Democrat Abraham Ribicoff knocked off GOP incumbent John Davis Lodge by 0.3-points in 1954.

Overall, 31 of New Mexico's 39 gubernatorial races since its first contest in 1911 have been decided by less than 10 points, or 79.5 percent - including Republican Susana Martinez's 6.7-point victory in 2010 over Diane Denish.

An astounding 17 of these races (43.6 percent) were decided by less than five points.

The Land of Enchantment boasts the narrowest average margin of victory across the nation since 1900 (7.5 points), since the end of World War II (8.2 points) and since the mid-1960s (8.7 points).

Former Democratic Governor Bill Richardson's decisive 16.4-point and 37.6-point wins in 2002 and 2006 belie New Mexico's recent competitive history: 11 of its last 13 races for governor have been decided by single digits since 1966.

Missouri and Montana have provided the next highest rate of close calls with 12 races each decided by less than five points (41.4 percent) across 29 elections since 1900.

Last November, Montana Democrat Steve Bullock eked out a 1.6-point win over Republican Rick Hill - the narrowest victory in the Treasure State since 1892 when Republican John Rickards defeated Democrat Timothy Collins by 1.2 points in Montana's second ever gubernatorial race.

Rounding out the Top 10 states for the highest rate of governor's races decided by less than five points since 1900 are New Jersey at #4 (40.6 percent), Connecticut at #5 (36.6 percent), Alaska, Hawaii, and Ohio tied at #6 (35.7 percent), and Illinois and Washington tied at #9 (34.5 percent).

Margin of Victory in Gubernatorial Races Since 1900 by State

Rank
State
# Races
< 10
% < 10
< 5
% <5
MoV
1
New Mexico
39
31
79.5
17
43.6
7.5
2
Indiana
29
15
51.7
9
31.0
9.3
3
Ohio
42
24
57.1
15
35.7
9.8
4
Alaska
14
10
71.4
5
35.7
9.9
5
Missouri
29
14
48.3
12
41.4
10.2
5
Connecticut
41
25
61.0
15
36.6
10.2
7
Illinois
29
15
51.7
10
34.5
10.3
8
New Jersey
32
16
50.0
13
40.6
10.5
9
Hawaii
14
7
50.0
5
35.7
11.0
9
West Virginia
29
20
69.0
8
27.6
11.0
11
Washington
29
16
55.2
10
34.5
11.2
12
Massachusetts
55
34
61.8
16
29.1
11.3
13
New York
38
19
50.0
13
34.2
11.6
14
Montana
29
16
55.2
12
41.4
11.8
15
Pennsylvania
28
17
60.7
8
28.6
11.9
16
Idaho
40
22
55.0
12
30.0
12.3
17
Kentucky
29
15
51.7
8
27.6
12.5
18
Kansas
47
26
55.3
14
29.8
13.0
19
Minnesota
44
21
47.7
12
27.3
13.3
20
Arizona
40
22
55.0
12
30.0
13.4
20
Wyoming
31
14
45.2
9
29.0
13.4
20
Michigan
45
22
48.9
11
24.4
13.4
23
Colorado
43
16
37.2
9
20.9
13.7
23
Oregon
30
13
43.3
6
20.0
13.7
25
Rhode Island
58
28
48.3
18
31.0
13.8
25
Maine
44
23
52.3
11
25.0
13.8
25
Iowa
46
18
39.1
11
23.9
13.8
28
New Hampshire
57
27
47.4
15
26.3
13.9
29
Wisconsin
47
21
44.7
9
19.1
14.0
30
Maryland
28
13
46.4
7
25.0
14.2
31
Delaware
29
18
62.1
9
31.0
14.3
32
Nebraska
45
23
51.1
15
33.3
14.7
33
Oklahoma
27
10
37.0
7
25.9
15.2
34
Utah
30
12
40.0
5
16.7
16.9
35
Nevada
28
11
39.3
4
14.3
17.2
36
California
29
10
34.5
6
20.7
17.7
37
South Dakota
47
13
27.7
6
12.8
18.1
38
North Dakota
46
17
37.0
9
19.6
19.9
39
North Carolina
29
7
24.1
2
6.9
21.5
40
Tennessee
41
10
24.4
3
7.3
24.6
41
Vermont
57
10
17.5
6
10.5
26.2
42
Virginia
28
6
21.4
2
7.1
26.6
43
Florida
30
4
13.3
2
6.7
35.8
44
Arkansas
51
5
9.8
2
3.9
45.2
45
Alabama
28
3
10.7
2
7.1
48.0
46
Texas
47
9
19.1
3
6.4
49.8
47
Mississippi
28
5
17.9
2
7.1
60.6
48
Louisiana
28
2
7.1
2
7.1
63.2
49
South Carolina
35
7
20.0
4
11.4
70.3
50
Georgia
40
5
12.5
2
5.0
73.5
 
Total
1,829
767
41.9
425
23.2
20.8
Table compiled by Smart Politics.

One state to watch in the 2014 cycle is Rhode Island - where Lincoln Chafee narrowly won by 2.5 points as an independent in 2010, but may file as a Democrat this cycle.

Rhode Island has the current longest streak of gubernatorial races decided by single digits at five consecutive cycles - with an average victory margin of just 5.3-points since 1994.

That is the most competitive margin across any state since the Republican Revolution.

If Chafee opts to run as a Democrat and wins the nomination, his path to victory might be easier in this blue state than by splitting the electorate into three slices as he did in 2010 when he ran outside the two-party system.

The three bordering Upper Midwestern states of Iowa, Minnesota, and Wisconsin (none currently projected to offer close-calls in 2014) are next with single-digit spreads in four straight elections.

Maine, Oregon, and Washington have three followed by Florida with two.

Florida's 2010 race between Republican Rick Scott and Democrat Alex Sink was the second closest in state history at 1.2 points - behind only the 1.0-point victory in 1876 by Democrat George Drew over GOPer Marcellus Stearns.

Over the last 30+ years since the Reagan Revolution of 1980, Illinois can claim the lowest average margin of victory at 8.4 points with five races in single digits and two decided by less than a point.

Illinois is also one of just three states during this span with half of its contests determined by less than five points (along with Minnesota and New Jersey).

Minnesota and Virginia are next at 9.6 points followed by Iowa at #4 (10.0 points), Washington at #5 (10.3 points), Mississippi at #6 (10.4 points), Alabama at #7 (10.5 points), Florida at #8 (10.6 points), and Indiana and North Carolina tied at #10 (11.3 points).

Interestingly, New Mexico is tied for the highest rate of single-digit victory margins in gubernatorial races during this 30+ year span at 75 percent (along with Iowa, Oregon, and Maine) but is one of only three states without a single contest decided by less than five points (along with Delaware and North Dakota).

Margin of Victory in Gubernatorial Races Since 1980 by State

Rank
State
# Races
# <10
% <10
# <5
% <5
MoV
1
Illinois
8
5
62.5
4
50.0
8.4
2
Virginia
8
4
50.0
1
12.5
9.6
2
Minnesota
8
5
62.5
4
50.0
9.6
4
Iowa
8
6
75.0
1
12.5
10.0
5
Washington
9
5
55.6
3
33.3
10.3
6
Mississippi
8
4
50.0
2
25.0
10.4
7
Alabama
8
3
37.5
3
37.5
10.5
8
Florida
8
4
50.0
2
25.0
10.6
9
Indiana
9
5
55.6
1
11.1
11.3
9
North Carolina
9
4
44.4
1
11.1
11.3
11
Oregon
8
6
75.0
3
37.5
11.4
12
Maine
8
6
75.0
3
37.5
11.6
13
New Jersey
8
4
50.0
4
50.0
11.9
14
Hawaii
8
4
50.0
3
37.5
12.2
15
Connecticut
8
4
50.0
3
37.5
12.3
16
Alaska
8
5
62.5
2
25.0
12.4
17
California
9
3
33.3
3
33.3
12.6
17
Texas
8
5
62.5
1
12.5
12.6
19
New Mexico
8
6
75.0
0
0.0
12.7
20
Wisconsin
9
5
55.6
1
11.1
13.2
21
Pennsylvania
8
5
62.5
2
25.0
13.9
22
Missouri
8
3
37.5
2
25.0
14.0
23
Arizona
8
4
50.0
2
25.0
14.2
24
South Carolina
8
5
62.5
3
37.5
14.4
25
Georgia
8
4
50.0
1
12.5
15.1
26
West Virginia
9
5
55.6
2
22.2
15.2
27
Michigan
8
3
37.5
2
25.0
15.9
28
Idaho
8
4
50.0
2
25.0
16.6
29
Arkansas
10
3
30.0
1
10.0
17.4
30
Oklahoma
8
2
25.0
2
25.0
17.6
31
Massachusetts
8
4
50.0
3
37.5
17.7
32
Maryland
8
3
37.5
2
25.0
18.0
33
Montana
9
5
55.6
4
44.4
18.3
34
Ohio
8
2
25.0
1
12.5
18.8
35
Kansas
8
4
50.0
1
12.5
19.2
36
Colorado
8
1
12.5
1
12.5
19.4
36
Vermont
17
5
29.4
3
17.6
19.4
38
Kentucky
8
1
12.5
1
12.5
19.8
39
Rhode Island
12
6
50.0
4
33.3
21.1
40
New Hampshire
17
5
29.4
3
17.6
21.3
41
South Dakota
8
1
12.5
1
12.5
21.6
42
Tennessee
8
2
25.0
1
12.5
21.8
43
Nevada
8
2
25.0
1
12.5
22.1
44
New York
8
2
25.0
2
25.0
22.3
45
Wyoming
8
2
25.0
1
12.5
22.9
46
North Dakota
9
1
11.1
0
0.0
24.5
47
Utah
10
2
22.2
1
11.1
24.6
48
Nebraska
8
4
50.0
2
25.0
25.1
49
Delaware
9
2
22.2
0
0.0
29.5
50
Louisiana
8
1
12.5
1
12.5
37.0
 
Total
435
186
42.8
97
22.3
16.7
Table compiled by Smart Politics.

Follow Smart Politics on Twitter.

Previous post: And the Most Notable First Lady Is...Laura Bush?
Next post: Can Mark Dayton Reach 50% in 2014?

Leave a comment


Remains of the Data

Is There a Presidential Drag On Gubernatorial Elections?

Only five of the 20 presidents to serve since 1900 have seen their party win a majority of gubernatorial elections during their administrations, and only one since JFK.

Political Crumbs

Strike Three for Miller-Meeks

Iowa Republicans had a banner day on November 4th, picking up both a U.S. Senate seat and one U.S. House seat, but Mariannette Miller-Meeks' defeat in her third attempt to oust Democrat Dave Loebsack in the 2nd CD means the GOP will not have a monopoly on the state's congressional delegation in the 114th Congress. The loss by Miller-Meeks (following up her defeats in 2008 and 2010) means major party nominees who lost their first two Iowa U.S. House races are now 0 for 10 the third time around in Iowa history. Miller-Meeks joins Democrat William Leffingwell (1858, 1868, 1870), Democrat Anthony Van Wagenen (1894, 1912 (special), 1912), Democrat James Murtagh (1906, 1914, 1916), Democrat Clair Williams (1944, 1946, 1952), Democrat Steven Carter (1948, 1950, 1956), Republican Don Mahon (1966, 1968, 1970), Republican Tom Riley (1968, 1974, 1976), Democrat Eric Tabor (1986, 1988, 1990), and Democrat Bill Gluba (1982, 1988, 2004) on the Hawkeye State's Three Strikes list.


Larry Pressler Wins the Silver

Larry Pressler may have fallen short in his long-shot, underfunded, and understaffed bid to return to the nation's upper legislative chamber, but he did end up notching the best showing for a non-major party South Dakota U.S. Senate candidate in more than 90 years. Pressler won 17.1 percent of the vote which is the best showing for an independent or third party U.S. Senate candidate in the state since 1920 when non-partisan candidate Tom Ayres won 24.1 percent in a race won by Republican Peter Norbeck. Overall, Pressler's 17.1 percent is good for the second best mark for a non-major party candidate across the 35 U.S. Senate contests in South Dakota history. Independent and third party candidates have appeared on the South Dakota U.S. Senate ballot just 25 times over the last century and only three have reached double digits: Pressler in 2014 and Ayres in 1920 and 1924 (12.1 percent). Pressler's defeat means he won't become the oldest candidate elected to the chamber in South Dakota history nor notch the record for the longest gap in service in the direct election era.


more POLITICAL CRUMBS

Humphrey School Sites
CSPG
Humphrey New Media Hub

Issues />

<div id=
Abortion
Afghanistan
Budget and taxes
Campaign finances
Crime and punishment
Economy and jobs
Education
Energy
Environment
Foreign affairs
Gender
Health
Housing
Ideology
Immigration
Iraq
Media
Military
Partisanship
Race and ethnicity
Reapportionment
Redistricting
Religion
Sexuality
Sports
Terrorism
Third parties
Transportation
Voting