Go to HHH home page.
Smart Politics
 


Tom Cotton's Quandary: Can House Freshmen Win Senate Seats?

Bookmark and Share

Only 17 House freshmen have been elected to the Senate over the last century, and just two in the last 40 years

tomcotton10.jpegIf Republicans are going to take back the U.S. Senate in 2014, one of their prime targets of opportunity is the seat held by two-term Democrat Mark Pryor in the increasingly red state of Arkansas.

One of the GOPers contemplating a run is recently elected freshman U.S. Representative Tom Cotton from the state's 4th Congressional District.

Despite the state's red leanings, unseating Pryor would be a remarkable turnaround for the party considering Republicans did not even field a candidate against him in 2008 when he took 79.5 percent of the vote against the Green Party's Rebekah Kennedy.

But on Tuesday a partisan poll was released that shows Cotton with an eight-point advantage in a hypothetical matchup against Pryor.

Cotton, a Harvard Law grad who later served in Iraq and Afghanistan in the U.S. Army, received 'rising star' status and national media buzz upon his arrival in Washington and an early Smart Politics review of media mentions of House freshmen in the 113th Congress found Cotton was ranked fourth among his colleagues.

Of course, making a move from the House to the Senate, whether as a freshman or otherwise, can be difficult even if a candidate wins his or her party's nomination.

For example, in the 2012 general election, sitting and ex- Republican U.S. Representatives had a rather dismal record at the ballot box: Connie Mack (Florida), Pete Hoekstra (Michgan), Todd Akin (Missouri), Denny Rehberg (Montana), Heather Wilson (New Mexico), and freshman Rick Berg (North Dakota) all lost.

(Former House and Senate member George Allen of Virginia was also unsuccessful in his Senate bid last November).

Only six-term Representative Jeff Flake was victorious - in Arizona's open seat race.

Meanwhile, on the Democratic side, U.S. Representatives Chris Murphy (Connecticut), Mazie Hirono (Hawaii), Joe Donnelly (Indiana), Martin Heinrich (New Mexico), and Tammy Baldwin (Wisconsin) all captured open Senate seats with Shelley Berkley (Nevada) losing in her challenge of incumbent Dean Heller.

But as Rick Berg's 2012 candidacy demonstrated, House Republican freshmen cannot count on a slam dunk, even in deep red states.

In fact, freshmen from either party have only won two Senate contests over the last 40 years.

A Smart Politics analysis of U.S. Senate election data finds that only 17 freshman U.S. Representatives have won a seat to the upper chamber since direct elections were introduced nearly 100 years ago.

One of those freshmen came from Cotton's state of Arkansas.

Of the 11 U.S. Representatives who successfully won a U.S. Senate seat in the history of the Natural State, Democrat J. William Fulbright was the only freshman.

In 1944, Fulbright defeated three-term Senator Hattie Caraway to nab his party's nomination and then cruised to his first of five general election victories that November.

The remaining 10 Arkansas U.S. Senators who had previous House experience all had served more than one term before their election to the nation's upper legislative chamber:

· 1853: Three-term Democrat Robert Johnson was appointed (and then subsequently elected) to the Senate after the resignation of Democrat Solon Borland.

· 1884: Two-term Democrat James Jones won an open seat race after Democrat James Walker opted not to seek another term.

· 1913: Five-term Democrat Joseph T. Robinson won an open seat race after the death of Democrat Jeff Davis. Democratic Senator William Kavanaugh, who won a special election a few months prior, was not a candidate for the full term.

· 1920: Four-term Democrat Thaddeus Caraway defeated one-term incumbent Senator William Kirby in the Democratic primary and captured nearly two-thirds of the vote in the general election.

· 1937: Three-term Democrat John Miller won a special election as an independent in a race held after the death of Majority Leader Joseph T. Robinson.

· 1942: After a four-year absence from the House, former two-term Democrat John McClellan won an open seat race after the resignation of John Miller. Appointed Democratic Senator George Spencer was not a candidate for the full term.

· 1978: After a six-year absence from the House, former four-term Democrat David Pryor won an open seat after the death of John McClellan. Appointed Democratic Senator Kaneaster Hodges was not a candidate for the full term.

· 1996: Two-term Republican Tim Hutchinson won an open seat race after the retirement of David Pryor.

· 1998: After a two-year absence from the House, former two-term Democrat Blanche Lincoln won an open seat race after the retirement of Dale Bumpers.

· 2010: Five-term Republican John Boozman unseated two-term Democratic Senator Blanche Lincoln with 57.9 percent of the vote.

Overall, these successful Arkansas U.S. Representatives had an average of three terms in the House under their belt before their Senate win.

Nationwide, of the more than 600 Senators in U.S. history who first served in the House of Representatives, just 41 were sitting freshmen at the time of their election or appointment.

And only 17 of these freshmen were elected to the Senate since direct elections were introduced a century ago.

South Carolina Republican Tim Scott was appointed to his Senate seat this January, and is the only current member who was either appointed or elected to the chamber as a freshman of the 52 with House experience on their resumé.

(Washington Democrat Maria Cantwell had served just one term in the House but was six years removed from the lower chamber when she won her first Senate race in 2000).

The average length of prior House service for these 52 Senators is 4.5 terms.

Over the last 40 years, only two freshman U.S. Representatives have been elected to the Senate: Kansas Republican Sam Brownback in 1996 and Minnesota Republican Rod Grams in 1994.

House Freshman Elected to the U.S. Senate Since 1914

State
Senator
Party
Year
Illinois
Joseph McCormick
Republican
1918
Oklahoma
John Harreld
Republican
1920
Louisiana
John Overton
Democrat
1931
Illinois
William Dieterich
Democrat
1932
Connecticut
Francis Maloney
Democrat
1934
Nebraska
Edward Burke
Democrat
1934
Iowa
Guy Gillette
Democrat
1936
Oklahoma
Joshua Lee
Democrat
1936
Arkansas
J. William Fulbright
Democrat
1944
Nebraska
Roman Hruska
Republican
1954
North Dakota
Quentin Burdick
Democrat
1960
Colorado
Peter Dominick
Republican
1962
Connecticut
Lowell Weicker
Republican
1970
Maryland
John Beall
Republican
1970
South Dakota
James Abourezek
Democrat
1972
Minnesota
Rod Grams
Republican
1994
Kansas
Sam Brownback
Republican
1996
Data compiled by Smart Politics.

Follow Smart Politics on Twitter.

Previous post: Can Mark Dayton Reach 50% in 2014?
Next post: Why Does Keith Ellison Keep Getting Primaried?

Leave a comment


Remains of the Data

Strange Bedfellows: A Historical Review of Divided US Senate Delegations

Over the last century, states have been twice as likely to be represented by a single political party in the U.S. Senate than have a split delegation; only Delaware, Iowa, and Illinois have been divided more than half the time.

Political Crumbs

Haugh to Reach New Heights

The North Carolina U.S. Senate race between Democratic incumbent Kay Hagan and Republican Thom Tillis may go down to the wire next Tuesday, but along the way Libertarian nominee Sean Haugh is poised to set a state record for a non-major party candidate. Haugh, who previously won 1.5 percent of the vote in the Tar Heel State's 2002 race, has polled at or above five percent in 10 of the last 12 polls that included his name. The current high water mark for a third party or independent candidate in a North Carolina U.S. Senate election is just 3.3 percent, recorded by Libertarian Robert Emory back in 1992. Only one other candidate has eclipsed the three percent mark - Libertarian Christopher Cole with 3.1 percent in 2008.


Gubernatorial Highs and Lows

Two sitting governors currently hold the record for the highest gubernatorial vote ever received in their respective states by a non-incumbent: Republican Matt Mead of Wyoming (65.7 percent in 2010) and outgoing GOPer Dave Heineman of Nebraska (73.4 percent in 2006). Republican Gary Herbert of Utah had not previously won a gubernatorial contest when he notched a state record 64.1 percent for his first victory in 2010, but was an incumbent at the time after ascending to the position in 2009 after the early departure of Jon Huntsman. Meanwhile, two sitting governors hold the record in their states for the lowest mark ever recorded by a winning gubernatorial candidate (incumbent or otherwise): independent-turned-Democrat Lincoln Chafee of Rhode Island (36.1 percent in 2010) and Democrat Terry McAuliffe of Virginia (47.8 percent in 2013).


more POLITICAL CRUMBS

Humphrey School Sites
CSPG
Humphrey New Media Hub

Issues />

<div id=
Abortion
Afghanistan
Budget and taxes
Campaign finances
Crime and punishment
Economy and jobs
Education
Energy
Environment
Foreign affairs
Gender
Health
Housing
Ideology
Immigration
Iraq
Media
Military
Partisanship
Race and ethnicity
Reapportionment
Redistricting
Religion
Sexuality
Sports
Terrorism
Third parties
Transportation
Voting