"Snow Brown and The Seven Detergents" by Banu Subramaniam was a wonderful article to read and discuss in lecture; it was an article that very much related to my life as a minority. During class Professor Garvey asked the class whether or not Banu's story of Snow Browns tragic life still relates to today's society, and a student in the class automatically replied with a loud "oh definitely not." My instant reaction to the students reply was defensive, and I felt quite appalled to hear that a student would believe that situations and experiences like Snow Brown don't occur or isn't happening right now, to this present day. What made the discussion really powerful was when another student spoke up and disagreed with the previous comment, and spoke of her personal experience as different race facing same situations as Snow Brown. You could feel the student's passion and intense connection to the article, and right then and there you knew that what Snow Brown went through is still present in the lives millions. What do you think about Snow Browns story? How does each detergent of Snow Browns story speak of the many problems that still occur today with race and education, careers and life in general? Do you believe that these problems still occur or not?
Snow Brown's Incredible Story
Categories:
No TrackBacks
TrackBack URL: http://blog.lib.umn.edu/cgi-bin/mt-tb.cgi/128382
2 Comments
Leave a comment
Search
About this Entry
This page contains a single entry by Avatar Aang published on October 14, 2010 8:35 PM.
Bleach for washing clothes? No more... was the previous entry in this blog.
Massive Attack is the next entry in this blog.
Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.
Categories
- 1: Introductions (Sep 8/10) (3)
- 2: Scientific Foundations (Sep 13/15/17) (24)
- 3: Inventing Identities I (Sep 20/22/24) (26)
- 4: Inventing Identities II (Sep 27/29/Oct 1) (25)
- 5: Beyond Dualisms (Oct 4/6/8) (17)
- 6: Feminist Science (Oct 11/13/15) (11)
- 7: Queer Natures (Oct 18/20/22)
- 8: Democratic Science (Oct 25/27/29) (1)
- 9: Animal Research (Nov 3) (1)
- 9: Environmental Justice (Nov 1)
- 9: Genetic Engineering (Nov 5) (1)
- 10: Biofears (Nov 10)
- 10: Diet, Health, Body (Nov 12)
- 10: Public Health (Nov 8)
- 11: Cosmetics (Nov 15)
- 11: Reproductive Tech (Nov 17) (1)
- 12: Floating Days (Nov 22/24)
- 13: Virtual/Realities I (Nov 29/Dec 1/3)
- 14: Virtual/Realities II (Dec 6/8/10)
- 15: Wrapping Up (Dec 13/15)
- 14: Virtual/Realities II (Dec 6/8/10)
- 13: Virtual/Realities I (Nov 29/Dec 1/3)
- 12: Floating Days (Nov 22/24)
- 11: Reproductive Tech (Nov 17) (1)
- 11: Cosmetics (Nov 15)
- 10: Public Health (Nov 8)
- 10: Diet, Health, Body (Nov 12)
- 10: Biofears (Nov 10)
- Events (5)
- Extra Credit: Film Reviews (3)
- Petri Dish (5)
Tag Cloud
Recent Entries
- Can You See Race?
- Women Scientists with families
- A Different Kind of Vision
- For Colored Girls
- The dangers of listening to others
- A Little Reminder about Situated Knowledges, Courtesy of The Onion
- The Vision in Flash Mobs and Mike Posner
- The Vision in Flash Mobs and Mike Posner
- Massive Attack
- Snow Brown's Incredible Story
Categories
- 1: Introductions (Sep 8/10) (3)
- 2: Scientific Foundations (Sep 13/15/17) (24)
- 3: Inventing Identities I (Sep 20/22/24) (26)
- 4: Inventing Identities II (Sep 27/29/Oct 1) (25)
- 5: Beyond Dualisms (Oct 4/6/8) (17)
- 6: Feminist Science (Oct 11/13/15) (11)
- 7: Queer Natures (Oct 18/20/22)
- 8: Democratic Science (Oct 25/27/29) (1)
- 9: Animal Research (Nov 3) (1)
- 9: Environmental Justice (Nov 1)
- 9: Genetic Engineering (Nov 5) (1)
- 10: Biofears (Nov 10)
- 10: Diet, Health, Body (Nov 12)
- 10: Public Health (Nov 8)
- 11: Cosmetics (Nov 15)
- 11: Reproductive Tech (Nov 17) (1)
- 12: Floating Days (Nov 22/24)
- 13: Virtual/Realities I (Nov 29/Dec 1/3)
- 14: Virtual/Realities II (Dec 6/8/10)
- 15: Wrapping Up (Dec 13/15)
- 14: Virtual/Realities II (Dec 6/8/10)
- 13: Virtual/Realities I (Nov 29/Dec 1/3)
- 12: Floating Days (Nov 22/24)
- 11: Reproductive Tech (Nov 17) (1)
- 11: Cosmetics (Nov 15)
- 10: Public Health (Nov 8)
- 10: Diet, Health, Body (Nov 12)
- 10: Biofears (Nov 10)
- Events (5)
- Extra Credit: Film Reviews (3)
- Petri Dish (5)

I completely agree with the post above. It is true that you have to experience discrimination in order to understand it and not simply witness it. We can all witness prejudice everyday and feel for the people instantly but do we feel the same the next day same time? Not only did I relate to the essay Snow Brown and The Seven Detergents but it also made me stop and realize where I am right now. I am a first generation immigrant and have only been in the United States for a few years. There was a huge cultural shock when I first started school. Not only was I thousands of miles away from home in a totally different world, but I was “different.” My race, culture, and religion were just the opposite of the people around me. People constantly asked me where I was from because they knew I looked different. I knew I was being treated differently than others based on my race, gender, culture and religion. I instantly knew I had to make some changes to fit in. However, first impression matter, so I was still being judged based on my color, the way I dress and my accent. No matter how hard I tried to look “normal” I was still different. One quote from Subramaniam’s essay that really grabbed my attention was “What happened to kindness, a little humility, helping eachother…Her family was going to hate her when she went back. They would not recognize her.” (233) This quote made me realize how we can be quick to judge and come to a conclusion about others based on stereotyping instead of accepting and celebrating our differences. We also get caught up by what people think of us and try to alter ourselves just to be accepted to the point where we lose our identity and don’t belong anywhere. I believe this applies to any group of people and definitely is a problem to this day. It affects our education, career, and life everyday because we live with it and not simply witness it.
I also enjoyed the article “Snow Brown and the Seven Detergents” by Banu Subramaniam. There is no question in my mind that the events and attitudes that were present in the article are still present today. We as a society should embrace difference. People from different backgrounds have different things they can “bring to the table.” I do believe that medical schools and other professional schools like graduate schools are more excepting of difference than they use to be. Furthermore, medical schools like to see people who apply who major even in things other than science. This is due to the philosophy that they will bring a more well rounded knowledge with them, other than just specifically a extensive science background and knowledge. Don’t get me wrong they still require that you take science classes like biology, physics, chemistry etc. In the article/story they always wanted Snow Brown to change herself into just a generic scientist. Where’s the fun in everybody being exactly alike? The world would be an incredibly boring place. The wide variety of different types of people with different kinds of backgrounds is what makes the world such an interesting place. In short, everybody’s differences should be respected and people shouldn’t be ashamed to be who they are.