Read it and Weep

user-pic
Vote 0 Votes

Chapter 16 focuses mainly on psychological and biological treatments. Psychotherapy is a psychological intervention designed to help people resolve emotional, behavioral, and interpersonal problems and improve the quality of their lives. A poll found that about 20 percent of Americans have received psychological treatment at some point in their life; however, some people choose to do "personal psychological treatment" as well. Every year Americans spend over $650 million on over 3,500 new published self-help books that promise everything from happiness, to wealth, to weightless, and more. Researchers refer to this as "bibliotherapy," (the effects of reading self-help books).

psych2.jpg

Only a small number of studies have been conducted to suggest that bibliotherapy can actually lead to improvements. In fact, the majority of self-help books are untested and they usually only address everyday minor problems. Often times self-help books promise unrealistic or far stretched solutions, which in return cause readers to feel like they "failed." Because of this Hal Arkowitz and Scott Lilienfeld offered the following recommendations about selecting self-help books...
- Use books based on valid principles of change and that have research support.
- Evaluate the author's credentials.
- Be wary of books that make far-fetched promises.
- Beware of books that rely on a "one size fits all" approach.
- Seek professional help rather then self-help alone when it comes to more serious problems
Self-help books and bibliotherapy should not be disregarded completely, but rather, people should be cautious about how much they can actually help with problems. Although bibliotherapy is better than no treatment at all, psychotherapy is best for dealing with more serious issues.

psych3.jpg

2 Comments

| Leave a comment

Excellent post. There is a definite need to be skeptical about pop psychology such as self help books. The best bet is to go for books based on empirically supported interventions. Martin Seligman's books, such as Learned Optimism and Authentic Happiness, are prime examples of good self-help.

This sounds exactly like what we were working on at the very beginning of the book/class with what information you should trust, just applied in a finding help format. Unfortunately, as long as there's such a huge market for finding solutions to the problems that we have in our lives there will always be opportunists trying to get in on the stake of money that can be made whether it be through legitimate desires to help or false help. I've found that everybody finds something that is wrong with their lives and so if one solution were to be solved, then another would certainly rise. A friend of mine always said "there's always something" and I find that saying to be rather true.

Leave a comment

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by whit1618 published on January 27, 2012 12:08 PM.

More than Words was the previous entry in this blog.

RESEARCH METHODS is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.