Beyond Nature vs. Nurture: Parental Guidance

user-pic
Vote 0 Votes

Why do some children grow up to be doctors, lawyers, designers, or athletes?
Whether children choose a profession because of genes or because of the nurture they get from their parents is still debated about to this day.

_47302609_dressingup466thinkstock.jpg

Psychologist George W. Holden at Southern Methodist University states his theory that "the way a child turns out can be determined in large part by the day-to-day decisions made by the parents who guide that child's growth." Holden also describes parents as being the "architect" of their children's maturation. Ultimately, parents have the potential to harm or help their children's growth.

Researchers just recently started to study the part that parents play in aiding or harming their child's growth in a specific path of development. Research on this specific topic is difficult because many other factors can come into play.

Holden has stated four vital ways that parents influence their children's development. First is that parents initiate trajectories, meaning they steer their children down a specific pathway. Second, parents endorse their child's progression through "encouragement and praise". This may include providing the access to certain activities, study materials, etc. Third, parents mediate trajectories by assisting their children in staying away from "negative trajectories". Lastly, parents "react to child-initiated trajectories". Besides these factors other possible influences on a child's developing path may be their "family's culture, their income and family resources, and the quality of the parent-child relationship".

family-of-4-199x300.jpg

It is interesting how much parents can influence their children in a positive or negative way and how they can influence their child's development over time. The article mainly discusses the aspects of nurture on children and it does not really go into detail about nature or genetic factors.


Article link:
http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2010/12/101202124244.htm

Image 1 link:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/magazine/8512576.stm

Image 2 link:
http://customhealthplans.com/blog/2010/01/add-spouse-texas-health-insurance-plan/

No TrackBacks

TrackBack URL: http://blog.lib.umn.edu/cgi-bin/mt-tb.cgi/177056

5 Comments

| Leave a comment

I agree with the article's and your view on a child's intended career path. From my own environment, my parents are very successful--my dad is a semi-retired business consultant, and my mom a retired chemical engineer. Growing up, they were always trying to guide me towards a high-earning profession. I've chosen my intended career path as a corporate attorney, and I often get remarks saying, "Don't choose to be a lawyer just because your parents told you to." It's hard to combat this response because, yes, my parents have very much supported the idea of becoming a lawyer over becoming a nutritionist. However, I feel that I wouldn't be reaching my full potential as well.

With digression aside, I believe the environment you grow up in ultimately decides the path for the rest of your life (albeit there are some outliers, of course.) If both parents are highly successful, you have a lot of expectations that you feel that you need to live up to.

I agree with the article's and your view on a child's intended career path. From my own environment, my parents are very successful--my dad is a semi-retired business consultant, and my mom a retired chemical engineer. Growing up, they were always trying to guide me towards a high-earning profession. I've chosen my intended career path as a corporate attorney, and I often get remarks saying, "Don't choose to be a lawyer just because your parents told you to." It's hard to combat this response because, yes, my parents have very much supported the idea of becoming a lawyer over becoming a nutritionist. However, I feel that I wouldn't be reaching my full potential as well.

With digression aside, I believe the environment you grow up in ultimately decides the path for the rest of your life (albeit there are some outliers, of course.) If both parents are highly successful, you have a lot of expectations that you feel that you need to live up to.

I, too, agree with both views represented in your blog. But, contrary to the success of hahnx214's parents, my parents simply work for companies, assembling a medley of items packaged to sell. This, of course, has been, and still is, the driving force in my life. To be concise, the fact that neither of my parents are successful is the reason why I want to, or feel the need to, become a doctor or what have you. I want to live up to the dreams that they dream for me. Whatever environment a child grows up in, the authors are correct in saying that parents influence the development of a child.

I believe there is a lot of truth to the theory expressed in this blog post and the original article. I wonder if this type of nurturing generally involves the parents consciously steering their child toward a certain career, or if the nurturing itself just subconsciously influences the child to pick a certain career, without the parents actively trying to influence them toward a certain path. Additionally, I wonder what kind of effect a lack of parental nurturing can have when it comes to affecting a child's career choice.

I think there is definitely a point to be made for families that gravitate toward similar career paths. I come from a family of many accountants and bankers, and as it happens, I am planning to major in accounting and finance. In one of my best friend's families, virtually everyone is in the medical or dental fields, and he is also doing the pre-med track.

I agree that parents can play a large role in their children's career paths, but I think there are other things that influence children more. I don't know what those factors could be, other than to say I think they are internal. My strengths and intended career path are completely different than my parents'. My dad loads trucks and my mom is a medical transcriptionist. I want to be a school counselor, psychologist, or an English professor. But I would say that their lack of success may have driven me to be more successful.

Leave a comment

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by bear0211 published on February 4, 2012 4:53 PM.

How Much Exercise do we Each Day = A MYSTERY! was the previous entry in this blog.

Nature or Nurture is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.