Peers vs Parents

user-pic
Vote 0 Votes

Our book contains a paragraph regarding the Peers vs parents argument, referencing a study done by Judith Harris. Harris proposes a group socialization theory, a theory that claims that an individual's peers have more influence than one's parents. This study, though questioned, deserves a more in depth look. Though most core influences are from our parents, the transition from childhood to adulthood can cause teens to purposely stray away from parental influences in order to obtain values and norms more socially acceptable by peers. If you think back to your pre-teen and early teenage years, you may be surprised how influential peers can be, at least I did. For me, even as a relatively young child I found myself spending a lot more time away from home, so much in fact that my parents once made "house rule" for my siblings and I to spend a designated amount of time at home each day, especially during the summer. Thinking back to the influences of my friends, though some fell by the wayside, a great deal of how I live my life today is a product of those peer influences, for better or worse. In this video, Dr. Gordon Neufeld discusses his book and ideas on the influence of peers, and even goes as far to say an individuals friends should not be near the top of the list of emotional needs. Though somewhat extreme, these idea are worth analyzing and applying to your own life. By all means, no need to watch the whole video, but do watch the first few minutes of the interview. Very interesting.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TwjDSPUX6zc

6 Comments

| Leave a comment

I would agree with the peers over parents argument. I think the people I hung out with in grade school and high school have had a major impact on my work ethic, language, and friendship habits. Luckily I hung out with some pretty decent kids!

Interesting topic. I would have to say it depends on a number of factors such as how the parents discipline their children and the child's level of respect for adults. Overall I think peers for sure have a much greater influence than parents. Sometimes our family are the ones who know the least about us, and our friends know us best and even shape who we are.

Interesting topic and I definitely agree on some levels. I think the main thing to consider is what you are doing at the moment either looking for your peers or parents influence. If it has something to do with getting a job, looking for a school, or talking with adults, chances are your parents are going to influence you more. Yet, acting in public, trying to be "cool" and things such as this, I would take much more seriously from my peers.

I would definitely agree with the peers over parents argument. However, I do believe that our parents laid the foundation of our values and influences and what is right and wrong. I would say that my peers made me the person who I am today.

I agree with the peer versus parent argument. My parents definitely influenced me as I grew up but during high school I strayed away from home often times not staying at home for an entire weekend and then only returning for the school week. During the summer I wouldn't be home for up to a week. Peers have influenced me greatly and finding what is socially acceptable has changed who I am as a person. But I wouldn't say that I have sacrificed any of what I was taught by my parents just incorporated both sides.

I think it depends, no one can deny parent's influence on us, we can have different kinds of peers around us, but we only have one couple of parents, the ones who share half gene and same blood with us. Most of us might have a period of disobedience to our parents, but I can definately say we will understand their position some day in the future. Peers do influence us in some way but, i don't think it as important as parents.

Leave a comment

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by lysne027 published on April 1, 2012 11:01 PM.

What to do or what not to do? That is the question. was the previous entry in this blog.

Say What? is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.