More TRBs More Troubles

| 1 Comment

2 years ago or so, I posted The Transportationist: The Trouble with TRB.

The Trouble has not been eliminated, and talks continue, I post an edited email from Georgina Santos on the same topic (reproduced with permission:

"Dear Eric,

Please find attached some numbers re: TRR.

Some people at the Transportation Economics Committee
Meeting suggested that the peer-review process was not
rigorous enough and the quality of the journal itself was
not great.

I don't have an opinion with respect to that issue but I
do know that TRR is not widely electronically available
and I strongly suspect that the main reason for that is
the price.

David Levinson suggested splitting the journal in different
strands. He will give you more feedback on that idea. One
important point about splitting the journal is that
university libraries may only subscribe to one or two strands
according to where their research interests are and in this
way they will make the journal more affordable to them,
as they will pay for fewer issues per year.

Lowering the price of the electronic version is another very
important strategy that could work wonders."

I would add that splitting the journal has several beneficial aspects, first is that it lowers costs. Second, for the healthy parts of the journal, they are not dragged down by the unhealthy parts, that is, there are better and worse committees of TRB, and which publish better and worse papers in TRR. Separation will allow the better sections have a higher impact factor. Finally, if they are separated, cross-citations between the several journals will be fully counted rather than considered internal self-citations.

Some data compiled by Georgina

Impact Factor
Transportation Science & Technology group of ISI
Transportation Res B-Meth 1.948, Rank 1
Transport Res Rec 0.206, Rank 17

The Price of TRR is
2009 2008
Print Only $4,475 $3,805
Print & Online $5,125 $4,450 (Online Access to 2008 Records Only)
Print & Online $6,425 $5,600 (Online Access to 2003 – 2008 Records)

In comparison

Journal of Transport Economics and Policy
2009: £137 / US $267

Transport Reviews
2009 Online Only £699.00 plus VAT $1,060
2009 Print & Online £736.00 plus VAT $1,116

Transport Policy
Online Only: $614
Print and Online $753

Transportation Research A
$1,788

One might add
Journal of Transport and Land Use
*Free*

1 Comment

Famous journals are already there, and good research universities can afford the cost; it should be noted that researchers in these universities are the main players. Not sure how much effort it will take to break the current "rich get richer" phenomenon and create a new one, unless the majority of the authors
can foresee the potentiality of the open source journals and are willing to take the risk.

David Levinson

Network Reliability in Practice

Evolving Transportation Networks

Place and Plexus

The Transportation Experience

Access to Destinations

Assessing the Benefits and Costs of Intelligent Transportation Systems

Financing Transportation Networks

View David Levinson's profile on LinkedIn

Subscribe to RSS headline updates from:

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by David Levinson published on January 20, 2009 1:49 PM.

The Stimulus Bill was the previous entry in this blog.

Unlucky Starbucks is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.

Categories

Monthly Archives

Pages

Powered by Movable Type 4.31-en