Sony HVR-M15U Mini-Review | Main | Mini-Shootout Videos

August 14, 2006

Mini-Shootout Stills

Please note, this blog has been archived and now lives at www.discretecosine.com

I'm still gathering up the footage - I may have found a way to get some of my variable bitrate XDCamHD stuff into a format I can use, but it'll take another day to sort that out. Similarly, it'll be about a week until the 16mm is back from the lab. In the meantime, here's some photos and some thoughts.

DSC02278.JPG DSC02282.JPG DSC02286.JPG

DSC02293.JPG DSC02295.JPG DSC02303.JPG

DSC02317.JPG

Overall, each HD camera showed strengths and weaknesses. I think that the Sony F350 (XDCamHD) really does belong in this group, because it's essentially a bulked up HDV camera. You get larger chips and better processing, but it's still 4:2:0 at 25mbps. Frankly, if someone is willing to consider the F350 a "professional" camera, they should consider the Canon XL-H1 just as professional.

We were using the Fujinon 17x lens, and I found it to be remarkably terrible. I'm not sure if we just had a bad example, but the chromatic aberration was even worse than the XL-H1. I need to investigate this further, if I'm going to give any consideration to purchasing one of these cameras. Because they use 1/2" CCDs, there is a much smaller group of native lenses available. You can get an adapter to go to 2/3", but I'm not sure what drawbacks that might have.

I'll post more thoughts and video tomorrow.

Posted by at August 14, 2006 5:06 PM | Misc

Comments