How Smart are Animals Really?

user-pic
Vote 0 Votes

I watched the "BBC Horizon" clip on consciousness and the study of finding out when humans become aware of who we are as people. The test used to determine when humans become aware of ourselves included placing a dot on the cheek of a baby without them noticing it being placed there, and observing if they notice it in the mirror when they look at themselves. This test showed that babies become aware of themselves at the age of 18-24 months.

mirror.jpg

When the younger baby looked at himself in the mirror with the unfamiliar dot on his face, he took no action to touch it or remove it. Next, when the 22 month old child looked at herself in the mirror, her hand touched the dot on her cheek immediately as if she recognized her face and it wasn't supposed to be there.

This study became even more interesting when they discussed the original idea used to test for self awareness which was to perform this test on animals. In this article, Of Conscious Thought and Self Awareness , it discusses this test being done on primates because they are evolutionarily and physiologically close to humans and are extensively studied in consciousness experiments. Chimps, pigeons, dogs, and dolphins are among the animals that have passed the mirror test. It is interesting to find out the extent of the knowledge of animals, and seeing as though many of them have the ability to recognize their own face, many animals may have deeper brain capacity than we think...

No TrackBacks

TrackBack URL: http://blog.lib.umn.edu/cgi-bin/mt-tb.cgi/178943

4 Comments

| Leave a comment

Wow, it's unbelievable how early we become aware of who we are. Our conscious mind is so complex that it can reach and develop within us before we are even 2 years old! I'm fascinated by this, because it makes you wonder how much a baby knows but doesn't have the ability to speak out or perform what he/she is discovering. This in sense also correlates with animals; if they can pass the mirror test, what other aspects of their intelligence do they have that has not yet been explored?

Self-awareness is a interesting topic to look at. It seems so natural to us that we know who we are and what we look like but for most animals this isn't true. I'd be interested to know what consequences being self aware has for animals like dogs and dolphins.

I find this article extremely interesting. Agreeing with the person above, it's crazy how fast our brains begin developing and storing information. I have to admit I am a little skeptical of this study. How often do these animals actually see a reflection of themselves? I guess pigeons, dogs, and chimpanzees may see themselves once in awhile in the reflection, but dolphins, what when they jump out of the water, they see themselves right before they re-enter? I wish they would have put more details about the study in the article. I can't help but wonder if the reaction is caused by something else, like possible their reaction is set off by the color difference rather then recognition of themselves.

Do you think that this is a good test of self-awareness? Could it be that it tests something like familiarity with mirrors (almost all of the animals who have been tested are very familiar with human environments)? Also, dogs have not passed the mirror self-recognition test (the article was incorrect on that). See more information here . Likewise, pigeons only pass with extensive training (again suggesting maybe this is just familiarity with mirrors).

Leave a comment

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by joh09252 published on February 19, 2012 10:46 PM.

Left Handed? Then, Different Minds! was the previous entry in this blog.

Art Taken to a New Dimension is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.