"Who IS that?"

user-pic
Vote 0 Votes

baby-in-mirror-so-we-meet-again.jpgAt the beginning of the video starring Marcus de Sautoy, he observes Gordon Gallup's mirror self-recognition experiment in person. In this experiment, the parent of a child sticks a black dot to the child's face without them knowing, disguised by them blowing their nose. Then, the child is put in front of a mirror. If they acknowledge the dot on their face, it proves they are self-aware.

When Sautoy was observing this experiment in action, he watched it being performed on two individuals. Owen was 16 months old and Bethany was 22 months old. When the dot was placed on Owen's face, he did not see himself in the mirror and recognize that there was something on his face. But when the dot was placed on Bethany's face, she did notice that there was something on her face via the mirror and tried to remove it. This concludes that Owen was not self-aware, but Bethany was. By doing this experiment, scientists have been able to narrow the window of time in which we become aware of ourselves to between 18 and 24 months of age.

Gallup also thought about how this experiment would work on animals. Out of all the animals he tested, only chimpanzees and orangutans were able to pass the test like humans. This video isn't showing this experiment, but it is showing how chimpanzees are aware of themselves in a mirror. This feat distinguishes the great apes (chimps, orangutans, and humans) from all other animals. This self-awareness allows us to "mentally time travel" so that we can think about what we've done in the past, what we are doing in the present, and what we could be doing in the future. The downfall of being self-aware is that we are also aware of the death of our consciousness.

After watching this video and seeing this experiment, I find it quite fascinating that we become self-aware at such a young age. I would have thought we'd need to be much older to recognize this. If we are aware of ourselves at such a young age, how come we can't remember memories from that young, too?

No TrackBacks

TrackBack URL: http://blog.lib.umn.edu/cgi-bin/mt-tb.cgi/179335

4 Comments

| Leave a comment

The fact that some animals do not even know of there own existence is a quite shocking statistic. It is difficult to imagine not being self aware. Animals like dogs, chipmunks, and bears do not have the brain capacity to know of their being alive. In the big scheme of things, it is quite a distinguishable feat to chimps, orangutans, and us to know that we are who we are.

I think the answer to your question is the difference in development of locations in the brain. Multiple parts of the brain don't develop at the same time so I'd assume that the part of the brain that stores long term memories doesn't develop before the part that allows us to be self aware.

One strange aspect of this experiment is that humans and chimpanzees are more closely related to gorillas than they are to chimpanzees. Seeing as gorillas share many of the same characteristics as the other great apes, I don't see how they wouldn't be able to perform the experiment as the other apes can.

Also, their operational definition of self-awareness is rather skewed. For example, I have often seen my cat look at himself in the mirror. Observing him, I would say that he knows that the surface is reflecting his image. This might mean that he is unable to discriminate his image from day to day or understand his reflection due to poor acuity. The definition of self used in the experiment seems rather tailored to the situation.

Do you think that the mirror test is a good measure of self-awareness? Do you think it necessarily leads to an understanding of death?

Leave a comment

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by bich0036 published on February 22, 2012 9:09 PM.

Prohibition! on sugar? was the previous entry in this blog.

The Brain as a Ticket to Travel.......out of your body is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.