A Prisoner or a Free Man?

user-pic
Vote 0 Votes

While looking up an article idea for the third blog, I ran across an article about experiments that showed psychology experiments that "proved humanity is doomed". While many of the experiment were looked over in the conformity discussion session, we didn't discuss the experiment that had the most dramatic impact on me this semester.

The article mentioned from above can be seen here.

The Stanford Prison Experiment conducted by Zimbardo had a chilling effect on me the first time I read about it. In the experiment, students were chosen to be prisoners while other students were selected to be guards. Zimbardo assumed the role of superintendent. The experiment was run for only six days, and in these few days, the students strongly conformed to their roles. The guards quickly let their responsibilities get out of hand, and Zimbardo allowed the experiment to continue. Even when the prisoners revolted, the guards didn't reconsider the experiment. In fact, the guards took further measures to subdue them physically and psychologically.

stanfordprisonexperiment.jpg


A documentary on the experiment can be seen here.

Throughout the experiment, the prisoners weren't actually prisoners, nor were the guards anything more than students. However, given the roles that they assumed, their reactions were genuine and harsh. They wanted the prisoners to feel as if they were imprisoned. Moreover, the guards wanted the prisoners to respect their authority.

Whereas the Asch Conformity Experiment and Candid Camera stunts were almost humorous in their premises, the Stanford Prison Experiment is borderline scary. While I disagree with the use of experiments such as these, this experiment shows so much of the human condition.

I want to remember what I took to heart from this experiment in five years. I want to remember how these people lost themselves, and as a result, these students harmed others. There is an evil that humanity is capable of when they lose themselves, and I want to remember that I must remain in the moment.

Theorist Claude Shannon has a maxim: "The enemy knows the system." Zimbardo will not be the last person to create a system that produces this breed of evil. Therefore, when a person like Philip Zimbardo puts the power into your hands, he knows the system. Be present in the moment. Don't become their system. Be the good in the world.

No TrackBacks

TrackBack URL: http://blog.lib.umn.edu/cgi-bin/mt-tb.cgi/187690

4 Comments

| Leave a comment

This is such a disturbing story. It is remarkable how in just six short days these students could be transformed in such a significant way. I would be interested to know the psychological effects of this experiment on the guards and especially the prisoners.

Wow, this is really interesting, I've never hear of this experiment. I think by now, humanity has repeatedly shown it's capabilities of hurting each other (the holocaust, Darfur, the Dirty War that happened in Argentina, the isreal-palestine conflict, etc.), and although I have no proof to back it up, I feel a large part of the cruelty humans have propelled on each other stem (in part) from a need to feel special or elite/ better than others. I have this hunch because of history and power hierarchies that exist all over.

However, despite the horrible things that have happened throughout the world and history, I think the absolute worst thing you can do is lose faith in humanity. I say this not because without hope there really is nothing, but also because the complete opposite of these abominations (love, community, good) does exist. Although I have not traveled internationally extensively, I have no doubt that where ever you travel, even in places rocked by war such as Iraq or places in Africa, you will find caring, kind human beings that will help you out regardless. Really, to lose faith in humanity is to only pay attention to the bad.

I think this experiment has such big implications on so many things... Just think about the prison system and the treatment that occurs to many prisoners. Before Zimbardo, the assumption was that people who were on power trips were the ones taking the guard jobs (no causation could be assumed). Because he randomly assigned people the roles, it showed that the situation and not the person was the big factor in this sadistic behavior.

Zimbardo was lucky his experiment even went that long. What ended up happening was obviously not what the participants, especially the prisoners, signed up for. One of the very few good things that came out of this was the greater attention to ethics in psychology studies.

Leave a comment

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by halvo317 published on April 29, 2012 5:06 AM.

Three important priciples in building a relationship. was the previous entry in this blog.

Go Ahead and Try to Lie is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.