« South African pres steps down | Main | Eden Prairie third best place to retire »

Students taking advanced math, not doin' so hot

The Star Tribune had this national trends story on its Web site Sunday about eighth graders and advanced math. Although enrollment in advanced math classes has gone up for years since the Clinton administration, the kids' grades have not been so great.
The call for more kids to take algebra by eighth grade was seen in the '90s as a "new civil right" because it was believed that algebra is a "gateway" class to higher learning. There was a push to put minority students in advanced math classes to give them more chances. A recent private study has shown, however, that kids are scoring very low and being passed on to higher-level math courses. Also, advocates of the practice of putting minority students into the classes worry this study will add fuel to opponents' arguments that minority kids don't belong in the classes.
"My big worry is people will use this to say, `Aha, see, it ain't working, let's put these kids back where they belong,'"
said William H. Schmidt, a Michigan State University professor of statistics and education.
Some think that math is a subject where you have to pass and prove you know one year's curriculum in order to be successful at the next, and if you don't eventually you'll just totally fail.
And still others think that passing through these classes is doing more harm than good, and speculate that the quality and challenge of the class is watered down.

It's interesting to read a national trends piece to see how the information is organized differently than just a straight-up report. Also, this is a really good article to serve as an example of an "attribution" story.