Nature vs Nurture in a social setting. Oh and some visual illusions.

user-pic
Vote 0 Votes

Yesterday i was thinking as i walked back from class about just how much of my personality came directly because of my genetics. More specifically I pondered how can my musical tastes be determined by chemicals in the brain. Does it have something to do with my experiences that associated the music? Possibly my parents attitude or lack thereof to my preferences? Or did it really all come down to whether my predisposed attitudes toward agression chose what types of music I would enjoy. And this lead into an even broader thought. How much of our morals can be attributed to genetics? Sure, close your eyes and ears for a second and you can still hear childhood lessons echoing and bouncing around your skull, but what of the kids raised in good homes who end up being criminals, or worse, lawyers! Or in the case of one of my cousins, a young girl who grows up completely despite her parents with seemingly innate morals.

This growing up despite bad parenting leads into the question of are others standing up for this girl and taking the place of surrogate parents? Is there a social obligation to do so? All are very puzzling questions, and I doubt there are any non-puzzling answers.

Oh and as promised http://www.ritsumei.ac.jp/~akitaoka/index-e.html
That site has a ton of cool visual brain twisters.

No TrackBacks

TrackBack URL: http://blog.lib.umn.edu/cgi-bin/mt-tb.cgi/188839

2 Comments

| Leave a comment

musical taste is something that isn't very determined by genetics as far as i'm concerned, but rather by what kind of music you're continuously exposed to. if people you value listen to that music as well, it's easier to try to like it.

for instance, in the past i wasn't a fan of hip hop. i used to be a more emo/metal/indie kind of guy. however, my brother started to get into hip hop. i was reluctant to like it for a long while, but the more i heard the more i came to understand the appeal. it helped that it was my brother that liked it, since it isn't like i could avoid the music forever.

you bring up your aggression as a reason for the music you like, and that could be the case. however, i also think what kind of music you listen to can effect your mood. for instance, if you spend all your time listening to sad music you may be more sad than if you spent that time listening to happy upbeat music.

morality. morality isn't reflected through genetics. if anything, basic human nature is. morality is something different, invented by humans to help maintain stability in society.

now whatever basic human nature is, i'm not sure.

While you posed some interesting questions that I hadn't previously thought about, this blog was a little broad. Also, the questions you posed left little answered, and I was slightly confused about that. What are your opinions on nature vs. nurture? What do you think has affected you more? Do you think it varies by person? I liked all of the ideas that you've thrown out there, and you definitely left me thinking. An explanation of the current views of nature vs. nurture, or some scientific evidence would have helped solidify this for me. I did, however really enjoy the illusions!

Leave a comment

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by annis024 published on May 8, 2012 11:57 AM.

Way to Happiness was the previous entry in this blog.

University of Minnesota is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.