Making Trouble
I was able to attend at the Walker Making Trouble, which was part of the Walker Art Center’s Women with Vision 2008: Past/Present film screenings. The film showcased many women in Jewish comedy not just today but as far back as Sophie Tucker, Fanny Brice, and the early days of Joan Rivers. The movie was interesting in that it was centered on 4 Jewish women comedians in a deli, discussing other Jewish comedians. The four women provided excellent commentary on women I knew little to nothing about and gave insight as to what it is like today to be a stand-up female Jewish comedian.
I really enjoyed seeing the footage of Sophie Tucker. I have read about some of her material but to see such a strong female stage performer from such an early time period. Her music is provocative, filled with double meanings and oozing sexuality. As with learning anything about the early 20th century, there is always this idealized purity that goes along with it. However, whenever I see footage of someone like Sophie Tucker or how in one of my classes I am learning gay history prior to WWII, it is encouraging knowing that our stifling of sexuality really isn’t deeply rooted in the past; sexuality wasn’t so taboo years ago as we think it was.
Another comedian I really loved seeing in Making Trouble was Joan Rivers. I know her from her E! red carpet specials, which isn’t saying much. She’s annoying, crass, overbearing, and needs to stop the Botox. That was the only impression I ever had of her prior to the film. However, since then I have an increased interest in her self-deprecating comedy and her devotion to her comedic craft. She had to work extremely hard to get where she is, working at clubs for no money and literally be yanked off the stage. They showed a lot of Rivers’ more recent comedy where she makes fun of her current employment on the red carpet. It made me respect her a lot more for what she does now, not just 30 years ago. She was able to make fun of the pointlessness and annoying nature that pestering celebrities can be. When she was interviewed she was also much more subdued. She wasn’t this crazy woman shoving a microphone in someone’s face; she is aware of what it takes to stay alive in the comedy business. Now in her seventies, she is still going strong and I guess now I feel I can really respect that.
Finally, one quote from the movie that really stood out for me was when Cory Kahaney discussed how difficult it was for her to do stand up when pregnant. It made her aware that on stage she was still a woman. It reminded her audience her woman status. I think this is reflective of how difficult it is for women still to perform solo on stage. You are a target for criticism and hecklers. People try and create a genre of women’s comedy and think that women’s humor can’t transcend genders. For some reason, there is a common humor amongst women that men can not enjoy. It raises interesting questions as to how far does a woman have to go in order to be considered funny by a mass audience? Does a woman have to embody more masculine characteristics in order to succeed in comedy? One thing that I have noticed is how inherently masculine stand-up comedy is. It takes a strong persona, sense of entitlement (you want people to listen to you, you think you are funny), and also a lot of confidence is needed to get on stage. Cory Kahaney’s one quote left a resounding impact on me simply because it raised so many questions and posed many problems still left within stand-up, many years after Fanny Brice and Sophie Tucker.
I know I left out a lot of the movie in my brief reaction. I was simply overwhelmed at the number of successful female Jewish comedians and also the commentary other had in response to their careers. I really knew of very few Jewish female comedians prior to the film. I knew of Sarah Silverman, Bette Midler, Sandra Bernhardt, and also Gilda Radner who was featured in Making Trouble. These women also showed how important it is to have role models and pay respect to those who have helped shape the comedic world (or any public sphere for that matter). Women are funny and it took a long time for people to legitimacy believe it. Certainly after watching Making Trouble it would be hard find someone in the audience that would disagree.










