When Stress Turns Into Success - 9/11 Study

user-pic
Vote 0 Votes

While previewing chapter twelve I read of the benefits of stress. Yes, I really did just say that stress can be beneficial. I learned that one of the ways in which psychologists study stress among people is from a perspective of "stress as stimuli." This field of study focuses on what effects particular stressful situations, such as pregnancies or natural disasters, can have on groups of people. The textbook highlighted studies concerning the effects of the 9/11 terrorist attacks on people's personalities.

Selected American citizens completed character strength surveys before and after September 11, 2001. When comparing the results of the subject's characters, positive strengths such as "kindness, teamwork, leadership, gratitude, hope, love, and spirituality" significantly increased.

Sept 11 (1).jpg

There is much that may be learned about stress from these results. I can recall the images of firefighters, the explosions, and Ground Zero that were circulated in the weeks following the attacks. Being young at that time, I can only imagine the magnitude of stress trusted upon our nation's government, families, and citizens. However, it is uncanny how the nation bonded together to combat this unprecedented stressor. This response or "stimuli" to stress was clearly reflected in the results of the strengths survey - proving that stress can indeed produce positive qualities in individuals.

4 Comments

| Leave a comment

I think that this is a very interesting observation, however I am curious about how long after 9/11 researchers continued to survey those affected by 9/11. Were these positive effects of stress temporary or did it continue to motivate these people throughout their lives? As everyone knows, the entire country felt much more unified and patriotic directly after 9/11 so I am curious if that was the driving force behind these peoples responses. Also, selected Americans does not necessarily sound like a random sample and I wonder if their response would be generalizable to the whole population.

I agree this is a very interesting observation, and I do agree with it for the most part. I know, relating to my own personal experience that when I am stressed out for a week or so with school, the next week usually flows very well for me especially after accomplishing everything that I got stressed out on. With relating to how long it actually lasts. I think it actually could last for a long period of time, because you would feel different accomplishing something, verses if we had never cleaned up the 9/11 mess and most of it was still unresolved.

I think this is a very interesting topic and I would have never thought that something bad could end up being beneficial. After thinking about examples of when stressful situations have ended up being beneficial I can see how they can easily relate to positive strengths. 911 is a good example of this because the United States came together after this tragedy. Today our country still comes together every year on the anniversary of 911. Another example of when stress can bring out good characteristics is a funeral. Many times families become closer together after the loss of a family member. I think stressful and hard times make people want to come together with others to express their feelings. Many people feel more comfortable being around other people during tough times because they have people to relate to and to know that they are not alone. From now on I am going to try to think of the positive outcomes that can come out of stressful situations to help me get through the tough times.

Before reading this chapter, I believed that it would discuss stress as I experience it with relationship problems and midterms but was surprised at 9/11 being discussed as a stress. Yes, 9/11 generated national pride and individuals coming together. But perhaps the success should be attributed to the bonding of people due to a common experience that happens to be stressful. The widespread reach of this 'stress' got people to uphold each other. When people are together, they tend to feel safer, braver, better. Perhaps it's the people, not the stress, that brings out good qualities in communities. Unfortunately, this sort of bonding is hard to stimulate. This is also relate-able to a political effect called the 'rally-around-the-flag' effect where public opinion on a candidate increases during times of national crisis. Perhaps this has more to do with optimism that emerges during crises.

Leave a comment

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by gross630 published on January 29, 2012 5:37 PM.

Blog Entry #1: Chapter 2-Research Methods was the previous entry in this blog.

Chapter 7: Memory is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.