Truth about lying

user-pic
Vote 0 Votes

pinnochio.jpg

In reading the section about Lying and Lie Detection I was honestly shocked about how many misconceptions I had about the subject. To find out that so many professions have the same 50/50 chance of spotting someone lying as any regular person was a little bit of a shock. I just always had assumed that those in police work and psychologists would be able to tell someone is lying. I guess I, like most people, have been watching too much TV. We fall prey to what I call the "CSI effect" and believing what they portray as real when it is not. Even those that administer a polygraph have the same odds as the rest of us for spotting a liar. There is no Pinocchio Response as we have learned from our book. Our noses will not grow when we lie. So if there is no Pinocchio Response how can some people tell when others are lying? I must admit that I seem to always believe the best of people and therefore believe them. Unless they have lied to be previously, then I would be a little more wary about what they tell me. Have any of you caught someone lying or had someone lie to you and you could tell just by talking or watching them that they were lying to you?

No TrackBacks

TrackBack URL: http://blog.lib.umn.edu/cgi-bin/mt-tb.cgi/184020

7 Comments

| Leave a comment

Yes, absolutely. Sadly enough, there have been times where I can tell someone is lying or hiding something because I have grown to know them so well. So when those times do come around, it certainly hurts to know that they are hiding something important. But, like yourself, when getting to know people or even with people I've known for a long time, I like the think the best of people. I like to prefer that most people in this world aren't going to try to rip you off or do something bad, but alas, we live in a cruel and unfair world. And I do the same thing as you do to assume that people of professions just do some things better than regular people.

I really like to see the good in people as well. I'd like to believe that most people don't lie, but it's actually a very common occurrence. For me, the only way I ever try to challenge what people say about themselves is when their lie is uncovered or if what they say is exaggerated beyond the statistical norm.

I am definitely one to see the good in people and have definitely fallen prey to lies from people but there are those few that you just know. The slightest facial expression or the slightest slip up are definitely the tell. I'm a huge fan of crime shows and was a true believer that professionals like those of the FBI or CIA would be able to call out any and every lie out there. It's a little discomforting to know that I have just about as good of a chance to do so as they do, my tendencies to look for the good in everyone however, make that an unsettling fact. I believe that liars should be called out and dealt with, but if it's only a 50/50 chance of doing so, it's a rough way to start off anyones day knowing that just about anyone can be lying and you wouldn't know it!

It would be extremely interesting to actually be able to know how many times we all get lied to on a daily basis. When we go around and interact with people, there are probably many times that lies are exchanged. Most of them are probably just "stretches of the truth" or white lies of little importance, but still! It would be interesting to see statistics on how much people lie, and even more interesting to be able to tell when you are being lied to. Too bad those cops on CSI aren't real...

I too used to think that detecting if someone was lying was a "science." I say science because I use to believe that there were tiny micro-expressions when someone lied because so many movies and TV shows portrayed this. Before reading this book I learned that that really isn't all that true but after reading that section I learned even more. One thing I would like to study is what parts of our brains become more active when we do lie and by how much. I think the whole concept is pretty interesting.

There are definitly people I can trust more than others based on the history I share with them. At first everyone I meet starts out on the same playing field; everyone is trusted. Unfortunatly, however, some people are just unreliable when it comes to telling the truth and/or exaggerating events. This becomes apparent as one interacts with them more frequently. For example, I know someone who will tell a story to someone about something that happened in which we were both there but he will make it seem a lot more interesting by enhancing the things that happened or even adding things to the story that weren't even there. These tendencies are an easy indicator as to whether or not someone can be trusted.

I tend to see the best in people as well. However, I do have a friend that I am extremely close to and I can tell whenever she is lying. I think the only reason I can tell is because of the fact that I know her so well so it makes sense to me that most people only have a 50/50 chance in telling if someone is lying when they do not know the person. Unless the person is really bad at lying, for example being really fidgety or sweating or just appearing nervous or guilty, I feel like it would be nearly impossible to tell if someone was lying or not.

Leave a comment

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by hinde053 published on April 1, 2012 11:52 AM.

Peek-a-boo, I see you! was the previous entry in this blog.

You, sir, are a liar and a scoundrel. is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.