Wellyopolis

July 11, 2007

You can't have a placebo effect of icebaths

Some new research questions the benefits of icebaths:

Ice-water immersion offers no benefit for pain, swelling, isometric strength and function, and in fact may make more athletes sore the next day

Then they find someone to question the new study, who says:
because it's subjective, there may even be a placebo effect on those who take the cold bath. Its part of their ritual, it finishes off the endurance test, and many clearly report that it makes them feel better

Now its true that you may get some benefits just from believing that the icebath works for you. But they aren't placebo effects. A placebo effect requires that you don't know what "treatment" you're getting.

If you're testing the effect of, say, drugs this is relatively straightforward. You give the placebo group a plain pill that looks like medicine. But even then, some patients will work out they're in the placebo group because they don't have any side effects of a drug.

It's impossible to have a placebo group in a trial of tepid vs. ice water because [nearly everybody] will be able to tell the difference between tepid and ice water ...

Icebaths are great. Right now I'm living in a climate where I get the icebath throughout some of my runs ... That is one good thing about a cold southerly in Wellington! It probably keeps the riff raff out, as they say.

Posted by eroberts at July 11, 2007 07:24 PM | TrackBack
Comments

So that's where the riff-raff are coming from!

These ice baths are fantastic for recovery. I don't know how one could end up sore from *taking* an ice bath. This sounds to me like a 'drinking water makes you thirsty' kind of study--one that gets after a well-established fact just to raise some eyebrows.

I'll stick with what works, studies be damned.

Posted by: Eric at July 12, 2007 01:50 PM

Full disclosure: Eric is employed by the Chilly Willy Ice & Paperclip Partnership, LLC.

It's a conspiracy I tell's ya!

Posted by: Mike at July 13, 2007 02:20 PM

Due to a recently revealed conflict of interest, Mr. Eric has been relieved of his duties with Chilly Willy Partners.

Now, back to regularly scheduled programming...

Posted by: Eric at July 13, 2007 06:18 PM
The views and opinions expressed in this page are strictly those of the page author. The contents of this page have not been reviewed or approved by the University of Minnesota.