CBS Early Show calls pig breast research a breakthrough

| 1 Comment

Take a look at the graphic below. Does it look like a pig's breast or like a human breast form? Because it was a centerpiece of a CBS Early Show story about research to grow breast tissue - and it's only been done in pigs.

breast ggx.png

But that didn't stop CBS' Dr. Jennifer Ashton from calling it a breakthrough with "potentially huge implications." Somehow, without any explanation, she was able to project that this might be used in women in 3 years - even though human trials have not yet begun. Wow, what a fantastic crystal ball TV docs possess!


Pertinent facts:

1. It's only been done in pigs.
2. It hasn't been done in one woman yet.
3. There are far more failures than successes in any research that makes the leap from animals to humans.
4. Anything that has "potentially huge implications" also has the potential for no implication.

That's why we favor a rational discussion of evidence - not breathless hyperbole. And that's why we don't work in TV news anymore.

1 Comment

I think it took a little longer than 3 years for Dr. Vacanti's ear mouse cartilage to be used practically. Looks like CBS was trying to put lipstick on this one.

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Gary Schwitzer published on November 13, 2009 7:49 AM.

Newer isn't better in treating clogged kidney arteries was the previous entry in this blog.

$100 hemorrhoid foam & health care reform is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.



Wikio - Top of the Blogs - Health

Add to Technorati Favorites