Pretty Little Princess
After reading the article “Construction of the Female Self: Feminist Readings of the Disney Heroine� and after participating in our class discussion, I am still not sure about what to take from this article or this subject of discussion in general. The way that these feminist critics look into each and every simple aspect of Disney movies, and try to see how they can depict them as giving little girls messages about being “the perfect girl� absolutely blows my mind. There is no psychological or biological way that girls in the age range that view these Disney movies can comprehend the implications these feminist activists are saying they do. These movies are a form of entertainment, what would be entertaining about a Disney movie if the princess did not end up with her prince in the end? I cannot think of a story that would appeal to little girls that solely involves aspects surrounding feminist ideas. I myself watched these movies as a young girl, and cannot think of a time when I thought to myself, or convinced myself that I was a girl and therefore I had to keep my mouth shut, be pretty and find my perfect prince. I think every child, regardless of what ideas they take from movies, will eventually grow to find that they are simply just Disney movies, and do not make significant implications for life in the real world. I thought the article and our class discussion were extremely over the top and almost ridiculous, the ideas the feminists pulled and manipulated from these movies were even over my head. I cannot think of one girl of the “Disney Princess� age that would comprehend those types of ideas. And once they do, they will be at an age where they are no longer basing their actions off of solely things they see in the media. They will be more influenced by their friends, teachers, siblings and family. At this age they will also be capable of making personal decisions for themselves, disregarding the ideas and expectations of others. I cannot think of any piece of media from my childhood that has anything to do with the personal beliefs, goals or expectations I hold in my own life. I know I do not need to live my life with my only goal being to find the perfect guy, I know I can be a successful person in the world without being a top model, and as we all know, I definitely do not sit back and keep my mouth shut.
Comments
I obviously agree with your article too, considering that ours are, as you said, almost identical. I liked what you said about Disney making a movie that embraced feminist theory completely. I’m pretty sure that no one would see this cartoon because it would lack all of the basic aspects necessary for a good children’s movie. There probably wouldn’t be any love, romance, or action. Disney is just basically smart at making, and marketing movies. Maybe they do lean a little towards patriarchy, and go against feminist ideals, but I don’t think that they do so purposely. Also, the patriarchal, and anti-feminist message that may be present in Disney cartoons isn’t obvious enough for little kids to notice anyways. Childhood is for enjoying oneself, and for dreaming. When kids become older, then they can read books and worry about feminism and patriarchy.
Posted by: Nick Olmanson | April 6, 2007 1:15 AM
I definitely agree with Nick as well. Disney has a very clever way with intgrating those feminist roles and ideas, but the kids watching are far to young to understand their underlying meanings andwhatnot. Disney is meant for enjoyment and when the kids grow up, then they can become acquainted with feminism.
Posted by: Christa Zilske | April 6, 2007 7:17 PM