The Strib today reported that, in a recent poll of Minnesota voters about University priorities, the goal of being ranked as a top national university came in dead last. University administration is trying to make the U of M one of the top three research universities in the world. President Bruininks acknowledges the "disconnect," saying, "I do think there is some natural tension. We are the land of populist thinking. But in a world of finite resources, we have to differentiate our responsibilities from other very valued parts of the higher education system."
Kids want to be on top, always. They want to be the best. They want the top bunk, the biggest dish of ice cream. When there's a bug eating contest, they want to eat the most bugs. When the coach says: "Jump higher, swim faster, play longer," they jump, swim, play their hearts out, wear their knees out, fast til they're toothpicks, bulk up til they're elephants. Simon says.....
From our leaders, maybe once in a while we could hear something that doesn't sound like it comes shouted across the playground at lunchtime, or chanted by somebody with pom poms and a little skirt. When President Bruininks says he wants to erode the pervasive hopelessness and resignation that drains our energy at every level of society, when he sets the university on a course to produce agricultural and medical and industrial systems that don't divide the rich from the poor, when he declares a war on stupidity and heartlessness at every level, I'll be there cheering. If he has the good sense to quote my old teacher David White about the supreme importance of "full humanity," I'll open up my ears and listen hard. But when he talks about being on top, I'll think about the kid who ate 34 grasshoppers and a frog, about the guy with the 16 foot ball of twine, about Jimmy the superlemming, first one over the cliff.
Posted by shea0017 at February 11, 2005 8:19 PMPeter,
Your comment on Bruininks' statement is alive and right. I hope you will send it to the editor of the Strib.
This is serious business. For leaders of institutions to speak up for serious values. For them not to condescend to the 75% of citizens who, where the University is concerned, care most about the education of their children.
I have just been reading Fritz Stern's book "Einstein's German World," about German intellectual and scientific culture in the period leading up to and through the First World War. The German research universities were the best in the world. They were well-connected with the great industrial companies of Germany. Their leaders were disconnected from and inclined to condescend to the great majority of German people.
There are sharks in these waters. Respect matters. Words matter.
Posted by: John Wallace at February 12, 2005 11:59 AMGreat post, being on top has become twisted
Posted by: Vertical Leap Programs at June 18, 2007 9:55 PMWow....Nice Post...
Who wants to be on the bottom?
Posted by: How To Get Your Ex Back at November 21, 2008 2:56 AM