I am going to do another one of those "here is how this entry came about" posts... so steel yourselves, dear readers, against an onslaught of randomness.
It all began in 10th grade. Mr. Bodey was my World History teacher. His class was insanely easy... I believe I finished with over 100%. He gave out candy for getting questions right, and once in a while, he would throw out a "Rich and Dreamy" question, a supposedly "tough" question which would entitle the first responder to one of these:

But that is neither here nor there. Mr. Bodey is most notable for the fact that, at least 2 or 3 times a week, he would begin class by playing Billy Joel's "We Didn't Start the Fire," the Piano Man's furious epic of 20th century history from 1949, the year of his birth, to 1989, the year the song was written. Mr. Bodey had a transparency of the song's lyrics, and at some points he would devote an entire class period to reviewing them point by point. I guess it was an effective, if gimmicky, way of teaching 20th century history. Mostly, I think, he just liked the song. (He also had a strange affinity for a band called "BoyZone." But that is also neither here nor there.)

Several years passed. I occasionally heard "We Didn't Start the Fire" in one way or another. It always brought me back to the good ol' days of Bodey's 7:50 AM history class.
This brings us to Friday, October 7, 2005. But let's back up a tick, to this spring, when I was burning a copy of Bright Eyes' masterful album I'm Wide Awake, It's Morning onto CD. The album is less than the full 80 minutes, so I decided to throw some random tracks on at the end. By fortuitous chance, Track 14 turned out to be "We Didn't Start the Fire."
So back to Friday. I was sitting at my extremely interesting and intellectually stimulating desk job in a state agency which will remain unnamed, staring at a computer screen, doing mind-numbing tasks while burning out my eyes staring at a computer screen. (But I would do that anyway, so who cares.) Since my job mostly requires absolutely no thought, just punching keys like a trained monkey, I am sometimes able to put on my trusty headphones and listen to music. On this day, I had me a hankerin' for some Bright Eyes, so I popped in my legal backup copy. When I reached the end of the album, I still had almost an hour left. So I decided to listen to Billy Joel. I disabled all the tracks but "We Didn't Start the Fire" and set Windows Media Player on repeat.
I proceeded to listen to this song ad nauseam for the better part of an hour. (Let's assume it was, oh, 52.14 minutes. Dividing the total amount of time by the length of the song (4.8 minutes) gives us a grand total of 10.8625 repetitions.) By the end, I was almost able to sing along to every lyric, if prompted correctly.
Because of Mr. Bodey's tutelage, I knew what pretty much everything in the song referred to. However, in the last verse, when Billy sings:
Foreign Debts, Homeless Vets/ AIDS, Crack, Bernie Goetz
I was unsure who this "Bernie Goetz" fellow was. I was also stunned by what hatred Billy Joel had for him to associate him with the plagues of the 80's: the spread of AIDS, the crack epidemic, the massive national debt racked up by Reagan's budgets. I resolved to do some research.
Well, it turns out that Bernie Goetz deserves to be lumped in with these scourges of society. He shot 4 people-- kids-- over 5 bucks. His excuse was that he was being mugged with a screwdriver. (The kids claimed they were merely panhandling.) From Wikipedia:
On the afternoon of December 22, 1984, four African American youths, Barry Allen, Troy Canty, James Ramseur, and Darrell Cabey, boarded the train on a mission to rob video game machines in Manhattan. Minutes later, Goetz entered the same train and sat down across from the four youths. A few minutes later, two of the youths asked Goetz for five dollars. Goetz, pretending not to hear them, asked them to repeat themselves. Canty responded, "Give me five dollars."The youths responded to Goetz's refusal by threatening him with sharpened screwdrivers. Goetz had a gun, a .38 five-shot Smith & Wesson, and shot his assailants, one bullet for three of his assailants and two for Cabey. All four survived, though Cabey was paralyzed for life.
After checking whether two nearby women were injured -- they were not -- Goetz refused to hand over his gun to the conductor and left the emergency-halted train. After Goetz left the subway, he rented a car, and drove to Vermont. He almost died in Vermont when he got lost in the woods where he went to bury the gun. He turned himself in to New York City police nine days later.
He was later convicted of illegal possession of a weapon, and served 8 months in prison. He also serves as a textbook example of why only the police should be allowed to carry pistols. [An aside: the new Florida law, allowing, basically, anyone to kill anyone for any reason, as long as you make up a good excuse later, scares me.]
In conclusion:
1. Mr. Bodey was a crazy teacher.
2. Mr. Billy Joel wrote a crazy song called "We Didn't Start the Fire"
3. Mr. Bernie Goetz is a crazy man who shouldn't be allowed back on the street.
4. Mr. Pat Smith has a crazy desire for his band Brad Halen to cover "We Didn't Start the Fire" in its epic entirety. (I just added that one now, but it's true.)
Bonus: Go to this website to see a charmingly crappy and tacky animation of "We Didn't Start the Fire."
Posted by smit2174 at October 8, 2005 8:32 PM | TrackBackThe only thing Goetz did wrong was not to kill those kids dead. I mean come on! "Two in the chest, one in the head;" its not that hard to remember!
Posted by: YourFace! at October 10, 2005 12:49 PMI'm going to copy/paste this into wikipedia under Sanctimony.
Posted by: BCH at November 22, 2005 1:32 PMOK, go ahead. I don't see how I was being sanctimonious at all... but whatever floats your boat.
Posted by: Pat at November 22, 2005 7:15 PMNice try loser, but they weren't kids, they passed adult-hood. One of them later confessed they weren't panhandling, but actually planned on robbing Goetz because he seemed an 'easy prey'.
Also from the Wikipedia: At the time of the incident, Goetz had no criminal record while all four of the men were criminal convicts with an aggregate total of nine convictions and ten outstanding criminal bench warrants, although only Cabey had been collared for a felony, armed robbery. When the incident occurred, all of the men were either 18 or 19, and had reached the legal age of majority. Thus it makes more sense to refer to them as "young men", rather than "youths" or "kids", terms often used by the media regarding this incident and also used by the civil trial lawyers for the four men, among them Ron Kuby and William Kunstler. Although not an exact definition, in a legal context the term youth typically implies that the person is under the age of 18 and may have some avenue to escape being tried as an adult.
At the civil trial, newspaper columnist Jimmy Breslin testified that Cabey denied his involvement in an attempted robbery, but said that Canty, Allen, and Ramseur intended to rob Goetz because "he looked like easy bait."
And: James Ramseur and Barry Allen have committed serious crimes since the original incident. Soon after being released from the hospital for the treatment of his gunshot wound, James Ramseur committed another crime with an associate: he was later convicted of raping, sodomizing, beating and robbing a pregnant nineteen year old woman on a building rooftop in the Bronx, and in 1986 was sentenced to 8 1/3 to 25 years in prison. Barry Allen committed two muggings after the shooting.
Next time, tell the whole story, and not just what's suitable for your propaganda. They got what they deserved and if Goetz had killed them, then he would've spared a lot of ppl a lot of pain and suffering...
Posted by: Sir Smoke at July 5, 2006 11:26 PMIdiot. First of all, Billy Joel wasn't "lumping" Goetz in with AIDS and Crack, it just happened to rhyme, douchebag. Second of all, Goetz is a perfect example of how citizens had to take their own self-defence into their own hands in the cesspool of crime that was New York in the 80s.
In short, I hope your dick rots off.
Posted by: Anonymous at July 13, 2007 11:18 AMIdiot. First of all, Billy Joel wasn't "lumping" Goetz in with AIDS and Crack, it just happened to rhyme, douchebag. Second of all, Goetz is a perfect example of how citizens had to take their own self-defence into their own hands in the cesspool of crime that was New York in the 80s.
In short, I hope your dick rots off.
Posted by: js at July 13, 2007 11:20 AMHello! Good Site! Thanks you! wlslewmmtwkw
Posted by: seuazvevyh at August 5, 2007 5:25 PMTypical liberal thinks only the cops should carry guns. Go to Russia or Cuba.
Posted by: B Smith at December 9, 2007 9:05 PMTypical liberal thinks only the cops should carry guns. Go to Russia or Cuba.
Posted by: B Smith at December 9, 2007 9:07 PMi think that that song is awsome and i luv it
Posted by: Billy Joel at January 15, 2008 10:31 AMThe original Writer has clearly never been on the fuzzy end of the urban violence lollipop.
NY subways were SO dangerous the City once put a patrolman (Transit Police) in EVERY car of nighttime trains. Then the budget was cut - but not the number of gangbangers, perverts, and other miscreants. I know; I was there; at 14 I was attacked on a crowded rush hour train and nobody even tried to help me. I never, ever, travelled the train unarmed. Bernie Goetz is no saint but he sure is EveryMan - Carrying guns may be undesirable but in NY (and Boston and who knows where else) people can't even carry Mace.
Comments