February 8, 2005
Jameel Guardian articles
Wall St Journal's online libel win brings 'much-needed clarity'
Clare Dyer, legal correspondent
Friday February 4, 2005
Judges at the appeal court in London yesterday threw out a libel action against the Wall Street Journal's online publication because only five people in England had read the allegedly defamatory item.
In a ground-breaking judgment, the court, headed by Lord Phillips, master of the rolls, ruled that internet publishers could not be sued in the English courts unless there has been a "substantial" publication in England.
Their ruling leaves Yousef Jameel, the wealthy Saudi Arabian who tried to sue the Wall Street Journal's publisher - United States-based Dow Jones - in London, facing a bill of £150,000 for the online publication's costs.
The judgment dispels fears that internet publishers could be open to expensive lawsuits in foreign courts after a ruling in 2002 by Australia's highest court.
The court held that a Melbourne mining magnate, Joseph Gutnick, could sue Dow Jones in Australia over an article in the online version of its Barron's magazine which had only nine Australian hits.
Lord Phillips, sitting with Lords Justices Sedley and Jonathan Parker, said: "It would be an abuse of process to continue to commit the resources of the English court, including substantial judge and possibly jury time, to an action where so little is now seen to be at stake."
Mr Jameel claimed that an article on the journal's website in March 2003 alleged that he was an early funder of Osama bin Laden before al-Qaida's leader started targeting Americans. The article contained a hyperlink to a document which he said referred to him.
Diet - Weight Watchers
Discover the biggest change at Weight Watchers in years....
Diet Patch UK
Kill your appetite in 2005 and never feel those hunger pangs...
InnerTalk UK Weight Loss and Diet CD
InnerTalk UK and Europe. Weight Loss Now CD self-help...
However, the journal could show that only five people in England had clicked on the hyperlink, including Mr Jameel's solicitor and two of Mr Jameel's business associ ates. The article was removed from the website in July 2003.
Lord Phillips said the damage to Mr Jameel's reputation had been "minimal".
No jury could be directed to award other than "very modest damages" after what would inevitably be a lengthy and expensive trial.
"The cost of the exercise will have been out of all proportion to what has been achieved," said the judge.
"The game will not merely have been not worth the candle, it will not have been worth the wick."
Mark Stephens, a solicitor acting for Dow Jones, said: "This is a significant decision for internet publishers. It starts to inject into the world of online publications some much needed clarity."
Libel action lost because only five people read story
Thursday February 3, 2005
A high court judge today overturned a libel ruling against a newspaper's online operations because technical investigations had shown that only five people in the UK had read the story in question.
The ruling in favour of the Wall Street Journal's American publisher, Dow Jones, has been hailed as a "major development in English law".
Dow Jones' successful appeal related to an original judgment in favour of Saudi businessman Yousef Jameel, who had sued for libel over a story on the Wall Street Journal Online website that falsely linked him to funding al-Qaida.
The high court today accepted Dow Jones' argument that the case was a waste of the court's time because it transpired that only five people had read the article. This is because, unlike printed newspapers, online newspapers can tell how many times any given story has been opened by a remote user.
The proceedings related to a story headlined "War on Terror. List of Early al Qaeda donors points to Saudi elite, charities", which included an interactive link to the so-called list of donors, which included Mr Jameel's name.
Lord Phillips said today there must be a substantial number of hits on a website to merit court action, otherwise proceedings amounted to an abuse of process.
Mr Jameel's lawyers said he began legal proceeding in the belief that the website had between 5,000-6,000 subscribers in the UK, according to Dow Jones' marketing information. It was not until later that it emerged that only five people had looked at the story.
iPod Offers from Apple Store UK
Buy an iPod or iPod Mini direct from Apple Store UK and...
Save on Apple iPod at Shopgenie
Save on Apple iPod at ShopGenie, the shopping search engine...
Buy iPod Online at the Apple Store
Find all iPods and accessories at the Apple Store: iPod...
The Wall Street Journal's lawyer, Mark Stephens, said the ruling has introduced a new substantiality test because it contrasted with a previous ruling in Australia that awarded damages against an online publication even though only nine people had read the article.
The ruling in 2002, brought by mining magnate Joe Gutnick against Barron's magazine (also owned by Dow Jones), was considered significant because it meant an individual could sue in Australia for an article uploaded anywhere in the world.
Lord Phillips said if there was a risk that the defamatory statements might be published on a wider scale then there might be grounds for Mr Jameel to pursue proceeding to get an injunction. But he didn't believe there was a risk in this case.
The ruling may also curtail so-called libel tourism, with foreigners suing in the UK to take advantage of Britain's favourable libel laws, Mr Stephens said.
Lord Phillips asked Mr Jameel's lawyer, James Price QC, why he had sued in the UK and not in the US, where the story was published.
Mr Price confirmed it was because "we obviously face a somewhat tougher legal regime in the US" and because his client was better known in the UK.
Lord Phillips said had Mr Jameel known the story had no significant publication in the UK, he should have sued in the US or elsewhere where more people had read it.
He also "stayed" the case, which means it will never be resurrected and awarded Dow Jones £100,000 in costs.
Andrew Stephenson, Mr Jameel's lawyer, said his client would be reviewing whether to sue Dow Jones in any other country.
The ruling was the second of two appeals today concerning the Jameel family. The Wall Street Journal Europe lost the first appeal against Yousef's brother, Mohammed Jameel.
· To contact the MediaGuardian news desk email email@example.com or phone 020 7239 9857
· If you are writing a comment for publication, please mark clearly "for publication".
Posted by stern130 at February 8, 2005 9:10 PM
You have a massive 3,600% greater chance of scooping a Euro Millions jackpot
if you play in an e-lottery syndicate.
The e-Lottery Syndicate System has got to be the best way to play the UK National Lottery and the Euro Millions - two of the world's richest, tax-free, lump-sum lotteries in the World. You can play from anywhere in the world. Winnings are sent directly to your home. Come and have a look at our website.
Web hosting provider of affordable, low cost blogs, e-commerce hosting, php hosting provider, leedsafety.net, free domain names, phone support, web based support, cheap web hosting, virtual dedicated servers, virtual private server, site builder tools, window hosting, low cost hosting, free domain registration with domain hosting, live chat support, No worry free web hosting
Web Design India | TheWebMento is a leading Web Site Design Company from India providing Website Design Services,e-commerce - provider , Multimedia Presentations, SEO, Web Page Des
ign, Software Development, Flash/3D Animations, Search Engine Optimization and Logo Designing. TheWebMento is based at Lucknow, India
Hello! Good Site! Thanks you! uqilnosossjk
Tacky Mats - Floor Entrance Mats tackymats.co.uk are the UK leading online provider of sticky floor entrance mats, Supply Sticky Mats, tack rags and wipes and sticky rollers.tacky mats,tackymats,tacky,mats,wipes,rags,sticky rollers,rollers,entrance mats,floor mats,easy peel,clean rooms,cleanrooms,health care,cleanliness,dirt,cumbria,uk
Great article. Can you checkout my free website when you get a chance?
Great post. Keep them coming.
Your Blog is very nice pls put a art page in your blog so that we can get more info on arts
You blog is very nice I am very lucky that I found such Blog now I would be reading your blog regular.
Thanks for providing good information on your blog.
Change what youâ€™re doing, and youâ€™ll change and master the art of personal success. Sometimes the best help we can give ourselves is self help.
You see when you want to help yourself you are automatically more motivated. You set your goals, you persevere and you achieve the things that you want to improve in yourself.
Every once in a while a classic book is rediscovered that helps the people of the world to make profound and lasting lifestyle changes.
It is surpising what people will do to to waste the judicial sytems valuable time.
Change what youâ€™re doing and youâ€™ll change what you get, as one of the most powerful selfhelp books on the planet professes.
Well, somebody is funding terrorists. And I think that people should know about them.
Web Site Design
I've been trying to find someone to write a write-up like this. I've ultimately found it after searching Google. Many thanks!
Thanks for submitting this. I am fairly new to social media and the blog traffic is over time increasing. I am fairly confident it's owing to me spending a large amount of time commenting on several other blogs. Not only would it get my blog available, but more importantly, I can keep up with what bloggers and readers are speaking about! I also spend quite a lot of time on Facebook together with Twitter...But I really need to reach out to other bloggers at my same arena.
Aw, it was an exceedingly good place. Theoretically Let me be able to write such as this as well : using instance and also genuine time to generate a beneficial article...still exactly what do THAT I suggest...THAT I put things a large amount and don't frequently get hold of a specific thing conducted.
You?re certainly glad just for this posting, I?ve long been definitely loving reviewing right up a person's reports every so often. Anticipating notice your potential discussions.
Hands down, Appleâ€™s app store wins by a mile. Itâ€™s a huge selection of all sorts of apps vs a rather sad selection of a handful for Zune. Microsoft has plans, especially in the realm of games, but Iâ€™m not sure Iâ€™d want to bet on the future if this aspect is important to you. The iPod is a much better choice in that case.
Pretty section of content. I just stumbled upon your site and in accession capital to assert that I acquire in fact enjoyed account your blog posts. Anyway I will be subscribing to your feeds and even I achievement you access consistently rapidly.
Eccomi, considero che quanto scritto mi trovi d'accordo :-)
Spot on with this write-up, I actually suppose this web site desires far more thought. Iâ€™ll in all likelihood be a lot of to learn rather more, thanks for that info.
Who do you guys think is better? Wiz or Curren$y? I'm having a hard time deciding since they're both so good. I think I'll go with Curren$y
Rolling Papers definitely kind of hurt Wiz Khalifa legacy since his mixtapes are so freaking good. I hope he drop Kush and OJ part two.
Your post raises some well-taken points, however I questions how many of them are really a important? That said, great post.
Its like you read my mind! You seem to know a lot about this, like you wrote the book in it or something. I think that you could do with a few pics to drive the message home a bit, but other than that, this is great blog. A fantastic read. I will definitely be back.
I keep listening to the newscast talk about receiving boundless online grant applications so I have been looking around for the most excellent site to get one. Could you tell me please, where could i find some?
This is a flawless blog entry, but sometimes I think I have to disagree with your takes and ideas on certain topics. On the other hand, I just cannot stop reading what you blog about because it is written so flawless and straight to the point. It's good to know that other people still take the time to think about what they are blogging about. I have a mastic siding related blog and if you are interested it would be great if you could have a look. I am just starting out and I could use a few instructions or pointers. Hopefully some day my blog can be as good as yours and I will have visitors that actually leave comments. Anyway sorry for the long post and I hope you continue to post on your blog unlike other people who just randomly quit. Thank you and I'll be coming back again!
I cling on to listening to the news talk about getting free online grant applications so I have been looking around for the finest site to get one. Could you advise me please, where could i get some?
Lovely just what I was looking for.Thanks to the author for taking his time on this one.
Probiotics are AWESOME, but most of the ones you buy (and pay good money for) only get absorbed into your body on minimal levels. Say you pay $100 for a good probiotic, your body is only absorbing like $3 worth of it into your system.
I suppose the main idea all boils down to who are your people and family. This had a lot to do with how your expressing yourself and what to check in the meantime.
In my humble oppinion, your article provides the public with everything they want.
Well crafted article, and that i as well currently grasped that many groups will be more willing as compared to others (considering that everyone is exclusive) might share the identical concept. I think you will save this blog working well.
It would not have said it any diffrent. Good looking out
1 comment for line no even space untill comments and comments.... Your comment about something, i suggest too be it more long as possible Ur1: hxxp://yourwebsitecom (don't even use the stadard format or you will be detected from anti-spam)
Really serious material on this topic. Looking forward to seeing more from you later.
Hi, I totally agree with you! Just obey my previous comment
grando eiranho de desos y cronos con adimpravo triaso. inhalo a maioro y geriot prererg con dislol agias!
All I can say is WOW! Branding things by one name or another may be wrong... but this is too perfect not to group it into greatness. This is a big :) in my books!
is so refreshing to find an article that gives us the general public everything we want...keep up the good work.
is so refre4sdhing to find an article that gives us the public everything we want. keep up ther good work. Julie
the thing is........150,000 to wealthy Saudi Arabians is but a mere drop in the ocean!!
We appreciate your posts and look forward to coming back
Formant votre chien marcher simplement le long de provoquer prend du temps.
You forced great ideas right here. I done a research on the topic and learnt virtually all peoples should agree with your weblog. One of the much more extraordinary methods to consider will be definetely to alter the roof of your room.
Good post, well put together. Thanks. I will be back soon to check out for updates. Cheers
Thank you for another essential article. Where else could anyone get that kind of information in such a complete way of writing?Kind regards from Italy.
I look forward to diggin more of your quality content.
Major thanks for the blog.Much thanks again. Cool.