Parlez-vous Bilingual? Reasons to learn a second language

user-pic
Vote 1 Vote

bilingual.jpgIn full disclosure, I am a staunch advocate of learning a foreign language. The topic of foreign language learning, immersion teaching in particular, has long been very fascinating to me. As someone who has studied and worked abroad, I greatly understand the practical benefits of knowing a second language but what has escaped my radar until recently are the cognitive benefits of being bilingual. Ch. 8 in the Lilienfeld text dabbled into these cognitive benefits. For a more robust understanding, check out this NYT article.

For sake of brevity, here are a few reasons from Lilienfeld and the NYT article why exposure to a second language before & after the critical period for language acquisition is so dang important:

1. Heightened metalinguistic insight -- this insight will be a friend that keeps on giving. You may think you know English now but it's amazing how much we don't know about the structure of our own language. Learning a second language has actually helped me better understand the finer details of my own native language.

2. Improvement of executive functions in the brain -- this includes planning, problem solving, and performing other mentally demanding tasks.

3. Brain efficiency -- executing demanding tasks uses less activity in the associated parts of the brain for bilinguals.

4. Increased resistance to dementia and Alzheimer's Disease -- a study found that the higher the degree of bilingualism, the later the onset of symptoms.

So here's my question: Why on Earth do American schools, with the exception of immersion, start incorporating foreign language education AFTER the critical period of language acquisition? It's clear that American students are having a harder time competing on a global scale with others. Wouldn't this be a step in the right direction?

Critical period of language acquisition aside, it never hurts to learn a new language. Do these proven practical and cognitive benefits motivate you to pursue learning a foreign language? Can you think of other benefits, besides the ones listed above, to learn a new language?


No TrackBacks

TrackBack URL: http://blog.lib.umn.edu/cgi-bin/mt-tb.cgi/183068

7 Comments

| Leave a comment

I am from India so I have been bilingual ever since I started school. Our first language in school was English but my second language was my mother tongue and that is the language we speak at home and with friends from the same state. Of course, I didn't realize that being bilingual has benefits till I read it in the textbook. But yes, there are some phonemes in my native language that are not in English. Also, Americans have been only close with pronouncing my first name in the way that people from my country would call it and my last name is a mystery to everyone outside India!!!
I did study French in my high school but forgot it due to lack of practice. I know to speak/understand few other languages from India. Now it makes me think that may be bilingualism at the early age helped this process. I would definitely recommend learning a second language. You will be surprised even learning the phonemes - the basic element of the language. Good luck!

Thank you for choosing such a logical and applicable topic to write about! I am also an advocate of bilingualism. I unfortunately cannot say I am fluent in two languages (yet), but I've had many years of German studies and was abroad in Europe for about a months time. I would agree with your claim that studying another language allows you to greatly hone in on your English abilities. I am much more grammatically conscious now that I've spent so much time studying the structure of another language and its relation to English. Also, learning another language allows for a greater depth of knowledge and appreciation for other cultures and areas of the world. Traveling is one thing, but being able to immerse yourself in the culture and communicate effectively with those foreigners is something that is unrivaled by most any other experiences.

While I am not fluent in Spanish yet, I am proficient in Spanish. I can read and write it fairly well. But, anyway, I do think it is very important to be bilingual. It gives you an appreciation for other cultures and understanding of other cultures. It also can give you a connection to another person who you otherwise may never communicate with.

I agree that America's schooling system is behind it's time. We don't incorporated many things that we should in our youth. One of the main things is that of teaching foreign language. As we've learned before we can learn foreign language better and more efficiently. Learning a new language later on in life has its benefits but also makes it much more harder. I would thoroughly enjoy knowing a second language to study abroad in a foreign speaking language. This would allow you to immerse in their culture so much better and allow you to expand yourself as an individual.

I agree that children should be taught a second language in elementary school. All research shows that it is beneficial for children! I even did a study on bilingual children while taking an AP Stats course in high school. Even though it took a couple of years for bilingual students to catch up to their peers who only spoke one language in English comprehension and usage, after those years, the bilingual children could use English much more proficiently! I think that elementary schools shy away from teaching a second language is because they are much more concerned as to how their students will perform on standardized tests. If they teach the students a second language, then their students will perform lower on English standardized tests than their peers in other schools!

I think that all school children should learn a second language in elementary school, as soon as they can! Many students take a year or two in high school and it's pointless because they forget everything. I went to our town's Spanish emergent school for my Spanish class a few times and it was amazing how fluent the kids were. We had been in Spanish for 4 1/2 years, and they had been in it for 1-3, and they kicked our butts! Also by learning Spanish I have learned so much about different cultures, just how to be aware of other cultures. But, most Americans are ignorant and think everyone should learn English...:(

That was a really great article from the NY Times Allison! I agree that the ability to speak another language is a huge advantage for people and it seems like the science is there now to back it up.

One of my biggest regrets was not working hard enough to learn another language. I did not take it seriously, learned it late (10th grade!) and was very embarrassed trying to use my 2nd language skills in Europe. Most people just suggested I refrain from butchering their language and insisted on speaking English.

I think there was a bias about teaching languages in this country for many generations to instill a national identity since so many of us are children of immigrants. I think there was a real concern that English should be exclusively thought in schools and that other languages discouraged to prevent ethnic cultures from gaining power and influence.

I struggled with second language because I learned late and I agree that the sooner a second language is taught the more likely it will be retained. I think the problem is that no one can decide which language to emphasize and that there are not always opportunities to use it in this country. Perhaps Spanish will become more accepted since Mexico is so close but we would have to improve our attitude toward immigration and allow Latin Culture to integrate more thoroughly into American Culture.

Leave a comment

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by lind1101 published on March 25, 2012 12:53 PM.

Killing Machines or Creative Geniuses? was the previous entry in this blog.

Do whatever the heck you want or Do exactly what I say or you're grounded? is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.